Mushroom Compost: Does It Smell Bad?

Mushroom compost is a popular addition to gardening and soil amendment, but does it smell? Mushroom compost, or spent mushroom substrate (SMS), is made from a combination of wheat straw, dried blood, gypsum, lime, manure, and other materials. While it is marketed as a beneficial product for soil and plants, its smell can vary. Some describe the scent as sharp, similar to tar, or not unpleasant, while others note that it can have a strong vinegar, sour milk, or rotten egg odour. This indicates the presence of alcohol, which is toxic to plant roots. The smell of mushroom compost depends on various factors, including the specific materials used, the composting process, and the age of the compost.

Mushroom compost is not real compost

Mushroom compost is a great soil amendment that retains water well, stops soil compaction, and helps break down dense clay. It can be a wonderful addition to gardening efforts, improving soil structure and moisture retention. However, it is important to note that it is not suitable for all soils and plants. For example, it should be avoided when using acid-loving plants. The main thing to remember is to research the specific plant's compatibility with mushroom compost or conduct a side-by-side trial.

Mushroom compost often contains chalk, which can reduce the pH of acid soils and have a fertilizing effect. It is also high in salt and unstable organic material, so it is advisable to leave it to mature before use. The salt content is usually not a problem unless used in large quantities or with soils that already have high salt levels or alkaline properties.

Some people rave about the benefits of mushroom compost for their soil and plants, but it is important to consider various factors, such as soil type, plants, and quantity, before using it. It is also essential to distinguish between compost specifically made for mushrooms and spent mushroom compost, which has already been used for mushroom growth. Most gardeners purchase the latter, and its properties can vary due to the lack of a standardized production process.

It's called spent mushroom substrate (SMS)

When mushrooms are cultivated commercially, they are grown in a substrate, which is a material that provides the nutrients and environment necessary for mushroom growth. This substrate can be made from a variety of organic materials, such as straw, hay, sawdust, and manure. After the mushrooms have finished growing and are harvested, the remaining substrate is known as spent mushroom substrate (SMS).

SMS is a byproduct of the mushroom cultivation process and is considered a type of compost. It is called "spent" because the mushrooms have already extracted many of the nutrients from it during their growth. However, this does not mean that SMS is devoid of value. On the contrary, it still retains some nutritional value and can be used as a soil amendment or compost.

So, does spent mushroom substrate smell? The answer is yes, it can have a strong and distinctive odor. This is because the substrate has been colonized by mushrooms, which break down the organic matter and release various compounds in the process. The smell is often earthy and pungent, and some people may find it unpleasant. However, it is not generally considered to be a bad odor, and it indicates that the substrate is doing its job of supporting mushroom growth.

The smell of SMS will vary depending on the type of substrate used and the species of mushrooms grown. For example, substrates high in nitrogen, such as manure, tend to produce a stronger odor. Additionally, some mushroom species are known for their distinctive smell, such as shiitake mushrooms, which have a strong, savory aroma. Overall, the smell of SMS is a natural part of the mushroom cultivation process and is not harmful.

If you are using SMS in your garden or compost pile, there are a few things you can do to manage the smell. Firstly, ensure that the SMS is fully cured before using it. Fresh SMS can have a more intense odor, so allowing it to cure will help to reduce the smell. You can also mix the SMS with other organic materials, such as leaves or wood chips, to help mask the odor and provide a more balanced mixture for your plants.

SMS is made from wheat straw, dried blood, gypsum, lime, manure, etc

Mushroom compost, or spent mushroom substrate (SMS), is a popular addition to gardening and landscaping practices. It is made from a combination of wheat straw, dried blood, gypsum, lime or crushed limestone, poultry litter, cow or horse manure, and other materials depending on availability. This mixture is partially composted, steam-treated for sterilisation, and then inoculated with the desired species of mushroom.

While SMS is praised for its ability to improve soil structure and moisture retention, one common concern is its smell. The odour of mushroom compost can vary, with some describing it as sharp, similar to tar, or even resembling vinegar, sour milk, or rotting meat. These unpleasant aromas indicate the presence of alcohol, which is toxic to plant roots even in small amounts. However, it's important to distinguish between the smell of the compost itself and potential anaerobic composting bacteria, which can occur if the compost is wet and stored in a dense pile without regular rotation.

The smell of mushroom compost is influenced by its ingredients and processing methods. The presence of manure, for example, can contribute to a stronger odour. Additionally, the steam treatment used in production may not always eliminate all odour-causing factors. It's worth noting that the odour of mushroom compost tends to dissipate over time, especially after mulching.

Despite the smell, mushroom compost offers benefits such as improved soil moisture retention and the ability to break down dense clay. It is also a good source of nutrients and minerals for plants, although there are conflicting opinions on its nutrient content. Some believe it is high in nutrients, while others suggest it may be low. The discrepancy may arise from the different methods used to create mushroom compost, as there is no standard process.

When using mushroom compost, it is recommended to mix it into the soil during winter in preparation for spring planting. This allows for odour dissipation and ensures that any potentially harmful substances are broken down before planting. Leaving mushroom compost to mature before use is advisable, especially due to its high salt content, which can be detrimental to certain types of soil, such as those with high salt levels or alkaline soil.

Mushroom compost can be good for your soil

Mushroom compost can be a great addition to your garden. It is a wonderful soil builder and can help keep your soil moist. It is also useful for breaking down dense clay and improving soil structure. Mushroom compost is made from a combination of wheat straw, dried blood, gypsum, lime or crushed limestone, poultry litter, cow or horse manure, and bedding, among other things. The real name for this product is spent mushroom substrate (SMS), and it gets its name "mushroom compost" as a marketing tactic.

Mushroom compost can be a great way to improve the soil in your garden, flower beds, or anywhere else you grow plants. It is best to mix it into the soil in winter in preparation for planting in spring. When buying mushroom compost, it is important to remember that it may not always be completely composted and may have a strong smell. Some people describe the smell as sharp, while others say it smells like tar. However, this smell is usually not a cause for concern and will go away, especially after mulching.

Overall, mushroom compost can be a beneficial addition to your soil, but it is important to consider the type of soil and plants you have, as well as the quantity you add, to ensure the best results.

It's a great soil builder and keeps soil moist

Mushroom compost is a great addition to your gardening efforts. It is a fantastic soil builder and helps retain moisture in the soil. It also helps to break down dense clay and improve soil structure. Mushroom compost is made from a combination of wheat straw, dried blood, gypsum, lime or crushed limestone, poultry litter, cow or horse manure, and bedding. The material is partially composted and then steam-treated to kill off any unwanted microbes.

Mushroom compost can be a great soil amendment, especially for acid soils. It can help to improve soil structure and retain water, which is beneficial for plants that require moist soil. However, it is important to note that mushroom compost may not be suitable for all plants and soils. It is best to avoid using it with acid-loving plants, and it may have a fertilizing effect on soils with high salt levels.

When purchasing mushroom compost, it is common to come across "spent mushroom substrate" (SMS), which is a byproduct of mushroom farming. SMS often contains high levels of salt and unstable organic material, so it is advisable to allow it to mature before use. Fresh SMS can be toxic to plant roots due to the presence of alcohol. However, in soils with lots of rainfall, the water can help wash out and leach the salts.

Mushroom compost will typically have a smell, especially if it has been bagged. The odour can vary, with some describing it as sharp rather than a pleasant, fresh scent. The smell is usually not a cause for concern and should dissipate over time, especially after mulching. However, if the compost smells like vinegar, sour milk, vomit, or rotten eggs, it indicates the presence of alcohol, which is toxic to plant roots.

Frequently asked questions