Magic Mushrooms: Do Stems Contain Psilocybin?

The stems of all edible mushrooms are technically edible, but some are easier and tastier to consume than others. For example, the stems of king oyster mushrooms are considered the best part of the fungus, while portobello stems can get tough and woody. Some mushroom stems are perfect for soups, stews, and broths because of their nutty, umami flavor. However, it is always recommended to cook mushrooms before eating them, as raw mushrooms may be difficult for the stomach to break down.

Edibility depends on mushroom type

Edibility depends on the type of mushroom. Edible mushrooms are the fleshy fruit bodies of several macrofungi species. They are defined by the absence of poisonous effects and their desirable taste and aroma. Some common edible mushrooms include white button mushrooms, cremini, portobellos, shiitake, and maitake. These mushrooms are typically safe to consume raw or cooked, but it's important to identify them correctly, especially when foraging wild mushrooms, as some poisonous species closely resemble edible ones.

While the stems of most edible mushrooms are also edible, certain varieties develop tough and woody stems that are unpleasant to eat. For example, the stems of shiitake mushrooms are often removed due to their tough texture, although they can be finely diced and added to soups. Portobello stems also tend to become woody, while the stems of king oyster mushrooms are considered a delicacy. Chanterelle mushrooms, known for their apricot-like scent, are another popular edible variety but be cautious as false chanterelles, which are non-edible, grow throughout North America.

Morel mushrooms, which are highly prized and used in French cuisine, have edible stems but require a good scrub to clean. Porcini mushrooms, also known as "hog mushrooms," are another type with edible stems. They are sought after for their reddish-brown caps and white stems, and they are commonly used in risottos or pasta dishes.

It's important to note that while all parts of an edible mushroom are technically edible, consuming raw mushrooms is not recommended as they may be challenging for the stomach to digest. Cooking mushrooms properly ensures a better culinary experience and makes the nutrients more accessible. Additionally, wild mushrooms should always be correctly identified before consumption to avoid accidental poisoning. Some poisonous mushrooms that resemble edible varieties include the death cap (Amanita phalloides) and Amanita muscaria (fly agaric).

Stems can be woody

While the stems of some mushrooms are edible, others can be woody and tough. The stems of white button, crimini, portabella, oyster, and king oyster mushrooms are entirely edible and savoury. However, the stems of shiitake mushrooms are woody and tough to chew, and it is recommended to remove them before cooking. Similarly, the stems of enoki and maitake mushrooms need to be trimmed to ensure their unique flavours shine through.

Baby bella stems can also become woody as the mushrooms mature, but the stems of button stage mushrooms are soft and edible. Chanterelle stems are also known to be woody and tough, and are often discarded before cooking. In contrast, the stems of king oyster mushrooms are considered the best part of the mushroom.

The stems of cremini mushrooms should be trimmed before cooking, and the gills of portobellos should be scooped out before stuffing or grilling. While the stems of shiitake mushrooms are often discarded due to their woody texture, they can be used in stocks or gravy if finely chopped. Similarly, shiitake stems can be used to make a velvety mushroom soup, which calls for more stems than caps.

It is worth noting that the stems of all edible mushrooms are edible, but uncooked mushrooms may be difficult for the stomach to break down. Additionally, the caps and stems of mushrooms cook differently, and some recipes may require the removal of stems to achieve the desired texture or taste.

Stems are edible when cooked

When preparing button mushrooms, also known as crimini, portobello, white, or brown mushrooms, the stems are edible but may require slightly longer cooking to make them as tender as the caps. Enoki mushrooms, commonly used in East Asian cuisine, are another variety where both the stems and caps can be eaten. However, the cultivated version of enoki has longer stems due to being grown in a dark, carbon dioxide-rich environment, whereas wild enoki has shorter stems and a peach-to-brown colour.

Shiitake mushrooms are often queried due to their tough and woody stems. While some people discard the stems and only use the caps, shiitake stems can enhance the flavour of soups, stews, and broths with their nutty, umami taste. Similarly, morel mushrooms are sought after for their amazing flavour, but their stems must be cooked first to break down toxic constituents.

While some sources state that all edible mushrooms are edible when cooked, it is generally not recommended to eat mushrooms raw. Cooking improves their taste and texture by breaking down chitin, a fibrous substance forming mushroom cell walls, making the mushrooms easier for the stomach to process.

Stems are more flavourful

The "caps vs. stems" debate has been a long-standing discussion within the magic mushroom community. While some people believe that the caps of mushrooms contain more psilocybin and are therefore more flavourful, others argue that the stems are just as potent.

Psilocybin is a hallucinogenic chemical found in certain types of mushrooms, commonly known as "magic mushrooms". These mushrooms are sought after for their psychoactive effects, which can include hallucinations and altered states of consciousness. The potency of psilocybin in magic mushrooms can vary, and it is generally accepted that the caps of these mushrooms tend to have a higher concentration of psilocybin than the stems.

However, it is important to note that both the stems and caps of magic mushrooms contain significant amounts of psilocybin. According to Nick Jikomes, a Ph.D. in the cannabis research discipline, while the caps may have a slightly higher potency, both parts of the mushroom can generate a high and should not be discarded. This is supported by Noah Novello, a cannabis and psilocybin lab owner, who states that the potency can vary greatly even within the same mushroom, with some caps being up to 75% more potent than stems, but also instances where the stem is stronger.

The variation in potency between caps and stems can be attributed to several factors, including the species of mushroom, the growing conditions, and the maturity of the mushroom. Additionally, the method of consumption and individual metabolism can also play a role in the overall effects experienced. As such, it is important to approach the consumption of magic mushrooms with caution and to be mindful of the potential risks associated with their use.

In conclusion, while the caps of magic mushrooms may generally be accepted to have a slightly higher psilocybin content, the stems are still flavourful and contain enough psilocybin to be psychoactive. The debate between caps and stems highlights the complexities of psilocybin potency and the need for further research and standardization in the field of magic mushroom cultivation and consumption.

Stems can be toxic raw

Psilocybin is a hallucinogenic chemical found in certain mushrooms, commonly known as "magic mushrooms". It is often consumed in brewed tea or added to food to mask its bitter taste. Psilocybin mushrooms are abused for their ability to induce euphoria and hallucinations. However, it is important to note that psilocybin is a Schedule I substance, indicating a high potential for abuse and no accepted safe use under medical supervision.

While the stems of psilocybin mushrooms contribute to the hallucinogenic effects, it is unclear if they contain higher concentrations of psilocybin than the caps. The mushrooms, including the stems, are typically consumed in their entirety, leading to the conclusion that the stems do contain psilocybin. However, it is worth noting that the stems of some mushroom varieties may be discarded due to their tough and woody texture, especially after harvesting.

When it comes to the edibility of raw mushroom stems, opinions vary. Some sources state that raw mushrooms, including the stems, are generally edible, although cooking improves digestibility. On the other hand, some chefs and individuals express a preference for removing the stems due to their texture or potential toughness. It is recommended to exercise caution with wild or foraged mushrooms, as the general consensus among mycologists is to avoid consuming them raw due to the presence of compounds that may affect digestibility.

While the stems themselves may not be toxic, consuming raw mushroom stems could pose risks. Raw mushrooms may contain compounds that affect their digestibility, and cooking helps break down these compounds. Additionally, there is a risk of mistaking poisonous mushrooms for psilocybin mushrooms, leading to accidental poisoning. Therefore, consuming raw mushroom stems is not advisable, especially without proper identification and knowledge of the specific mushroom variety.

Frequently asked questions