Mushrooms: Oil Absorption Superheroes?

Mushrooms are a versatile ingredient used in a variety of dishes, from soups to stews and pasta. They are known to absorb oil quickly during cooking due to their spongy texture, which is a result of their high water content (80-90%). This can be a challenge when trying to achieve the desired texture and flavour in cooked mushrooms. To prevent them from soaking up too much oil, some cooks recommend starting with a dry pan to let the mushrooms release their water, which then evaporates, before adding oil or butter at the end of the cooking process. Others suggest using a small amount of water at the start to collapse the air pockets, reducing the mushrooms' ability to absorb oil. These techniques aim to produce tender, browned mushrooms without excessive oil absorption.

Mushrooms are sponges

Mushrooms are like sponges. They consist of 80 to 90% water, yet they soak up oil quickly during cooking. This is due to their spongy texture, which is caused by numerous tiny air pockets. These air pockets collapse when exposed to cooking heat, reducing the mushrooms' ability to absorb oil. However, if you add oil before the pockets collapse, the mushrooms will absorb it.

To prevent mushrooms from absorbing too much oil, it is recommended to start cooking them in a dry pan on medium-high heat. This causes the mushrooms to release their water, which then evaporates. Only after the pan is dry and the mushrooms have started to brown again is oil added. This technique results in perfectly cooked and browned mushrooms without much oil absorption.

Another method to prevent oil absorption is to use water as the initial cooking medium. Mushrooms are cooked in water for a few minutes until they release their water, which then evaporates, leaving the pan dry. Only then is a small amount of oil added to the pan to brown the mushrooms. This technique delivers tasty and tender mushrooms without the need for much oil.

It is also important to note that mushrooms should not be overcrowded in the pan. This is because overcrowding causes the mushrooms to steam instead of brown. Additionally, mushrooms should not be washed before cooking as they can become waterlogged, slimy, and soggy. Instead, they should be cleaned with a damp paper towel or brushed off with a pastry brush.

Water sautéing

To begin water sautéing, place the mushrooms in a pan with a small amount of water and bring it to a boil. The mushrooms will release their water during this process, reducing in size and cooking through. The oil-absorbing air pockets within the mushrooms will also collapse due to the heat, losing their ability to absorb oil. Continue cooking until the water evaporates entirely, leaving the pan dry.

At this stage, add a small amount of oil to the pan. This step lubricates the mushrooms and aids in achieving a nice brown colour after a few minutes of sautéing with frequent stirring. The mushrooms are now ready to be served or incorporated into other dishes or sauces.

Oil at the end

Mushrooms are like sponges and will soak up any moisture. They are composed of 80 to 90% water, and when cooked, they release this water. This is why they can absorb so much oil during cooking.

To prevent this, some cooks recommend starting with a dry pan on medium-high heat. The mushrooms will start to brown and then release their water. Once this water evaporates, the mushrooms will begin to brown again. Only at this point do you add oil, butter, or salt. This technique helps prevent the mushrooms from absorbing too much oil.

Another method is to add a small amount of water to the mushrooms at the start of cooking. As the mushrooms release their water, the water-absorbing air pockets in the mushrooms collapse, and they lose their ability to absorb oil. Once the water has evaporated, add a small amount of oil to the pan to brown the mushrooms.

Some cooks recommend adding oil gradually throughout the cooking process, finishing with butter at the end. This technique may work better with certain types of mushrooms.

It is also important not to overcrowd the pan when cooking mushrooms, as this can cause them to steam instead of brown.

Don't overcrowd the pan

Mushrooms have a high water content, with 80 to 90% water. They are also very absorbent. When cooked, they release this water, which then evaporates. If the mushrooms are packed into the pan, there is not enough space for the water to evaporate, and the mushrooms will steam and become soggy. Therefore, it is important to give them enough room to "do their thing".

To avoid this, cook mushrooms in a single layer, with about an inch of free space around each piece. This will allow the water to evaporate, and the mushrooms to brown. If you are cooking a large quantity of mushrooms, it is better to cook them in batches.

It is also worth noting that mushrooms should not be washed before cooking, as they will become waterlogged. Instead, they should be cleaned with a damp paper towel or brushed with a pastry brush.

Some cooks recommend starting to cook mushrooms in a dry pan, allowing them to release their water, before adding oil or butter. This helps to prevent the mushrooms from absorbing too much oil, which can make them greasy.

By following these simple tips—avoiding over-crowding the pan, not washing the mushrooms, and controlling the amount of oil they absorb—you can ensure that your cooked mushrooms are tasty and have a good texture.

Don't wash mushrooms

Mushrooms are like sponges—they will absorb any moisture they come into contact with. This is why many sources advise against washing mushrooms, as they can become waterlogged and soggy, which can affect their texture and taste.

When cooking mushrooms, it is important to avoid overcrowding the pan. Mushrooms need room for their liquid to evaporate; otherwise, they will steam. If you are cooking with mushrooms, it is recommended to start with a dry pan, allowing the water in the mushrooms to release and boil away. Once the mushrooms are dry, you can add oil or butter. This method helps prevent the mushrooms from absorbing too much oil, which can cause them to burn.

Instead of washing mushrooms, it is recommended to clean them with a damp paper towel or brush off any dirt with a pastry brush or mushroom brush. This is especially important for cultivated mushrooms, which are grown in pasteurized compost and can be gritty if not properly cleaned. Foraged mushrooms should always be washed to remove any dirt or insects.

However, some people argue that washing mushrooms is unnecessary and does not affect their cooking properties. They claim that mushrooms naturally contain a lot of water and that a brief rinse will not significantly impact their flavour or texture. Additionally, washing mushrooms can help remove any bacteria that may be present.

Ultimately, the decision to wash or not wash mushrooms is a matter of personal preference. Some chefs prefer to wash mushrooms, especially if they are dirty, while others choose to clean them without submerging them in water.

Frequently asked questions