Washing Mushrooms: To Wash Or Not Before Sautéing?

Whether or not to wash mushrooms before sautéing is a highly debated topic. Some sources claim that washing mushrooms is unnecessary and can even cause them to become soggy and less flavorful. However, others argue that a quick rinse is sufficient and can help remove dirt and debris. Ultimately, the decision comes down to personal preference and the type of mushroom being used. Wild mushrooms, for example, may require a more thorough cleaning due to their unsterile growing environment, whereas cultivated mushrooms grown in sterile conditions may only need a gentle brush or wipe with a damp cloth. It is generally recommended to wash mushrooms right before cooking and to dry them thoroughly before adding them to the pan to avoid excess moisture.

Explore related products

Chef’n 2-in-1 ShroomBroom Mushroom Cleaning Brush and Corer

$10.44 $10.99

Full Circle FunGuy, 2 in 1 Mushroom Cleaning Brush, White

$8.31

Joie Mushroom Brush and Vegetable Scrubber

$6.99

Cuisinox Mushroom Brush with Wooden Top

$5

Iris Hantverk Birch Wood and Horsehair Mushroom Brush

$21.25

Fox Run Wood Mushroom Brush, Nylon Bristles 2 x 2 x 1.25 inches

$7.72

Wild vs cultivated mushrooms

Whether you should wash mushrooms before sautéing them depends on the type of mushroom you are using. Mushrooms can be broadly categorized into two types: wild and cultivated.

Wild Mushrooms

Wild mushrooms are harvested in the wild, often growing on the side of a tree, at its base, or in your driveway or yard. These are unsterile environments that can host leaves, twigs, pine needles, dirt, and bugs. Wild mushrooms are celebrated for their complex and varied flavor profiles, often possessing a depth and intensity that cultivated mushrooms lack. Foragers and chefs alike treasure wild varieties like boletes, porcini, and chanterelles for their earthy, nutty, and sometimes fruity notes, which can vary significantly depending on their natural habitat and the soil they grow in.

Cultivated Mushrooms

Cultivated mushrooms, on the other hand, are grown in sterile environments more like science laboratories with sterilized compost, white coats, and sterile gloves. The bulk of the mushrooms you encounter will be cultivated, and these do not need to be washed due to their sterile environment and compost. All you need to do is brush them off with a dry towel or mushroom brush. Cultivated mushrooms, such as the common white button, shiitake, and portobello, offer a more consistent taste due to the controlled environment in which they are grown. They are also milder in flavor, making them versatile in a wide range of dishes.

Cleaning Mushrooms

When it comes to cleaning mushrooms, there are differing opinions. Some people believe that washing mushrooms can result in slimy and less flavorful mushrooms. These people opt for scraping or peeling the dirt off the mushrooms. However, others, including chef Alex Guarnaschelli, are proponents of washing mushrooms. Guarnaschelli suggests using a knife or a damp cloth to remove visible dirt, and only washing particularly dirty mushrooms. It is recommended to wash mushrooms right before cooking to avoid them getting bogged down with water.

How to wash mushrooms

Whether or not to wash mushrooms is a highly debated topic. Some people believe that washing mushrooms can make them slimy and less flavourful. On the other hand, some people are uncomfortable with the idea of not washing mushrooms because they are often grown in dirt and can be dirty.

If you decide to wash your mushrooms, it is important to do so right before you cook them to prevent them from becoming soggy. It is also recommended to avoid soaking mushrooms, as they can absorb water, affecting their texture and flavour. Instead, gently rinse them one or two at a time under a cold tap and rub them gently with your fingers or a soft towel to remove any dirt. You can also use a mushroom brush or an extra-soft toothbrush to gently scrub away dirt from the gills and smaller cavities. After rinsing, dry the mushrooms with a paper towel or cloth before cooking.

If you prefer not to wash your mushrooms, you can use a brush or damp cloth to wipe them clean. You can also cut off any sections of the mushroom that are holding dirt, usually the base or end of the stem. For wild mushrooms or those purchased from a farmer's market, brushing may be the best method to prevent damage to the product.

It is worth noting that cultivated mushrooms grown in sterile environments, which are commonly found in grocery stores, may not require washing as they are already clean. However, if you purchase mushrooms from a local producer or forage them yourself, washing or thorough brushing is recommended to remove any dirt or debris.

When to wash mushrooms

Mushrooms are a delicious addition to many dishes, but they can be a little tricky to prepare. The question of whether or not to wash mushrooms before cooking them is a common dilemma, and there are a few factors to consider when deciding how to clean them properly. Firstly, it is important to determine the type of mushroom and its growing conditions. Wild mushrooms, for example, are often harvested from unsterile environments and may require a more thorough cleaning compared to cultivated mushrooms.

Cultivated mushrooms, which are typically found in grocery stores, are grown in sterile environments with pasteurized compost. These mushrooms are generally cleaner and may only need a quick rinse or a gentle brush to remove any excess dirt or compost. Wild mushrooms, on the other hand, especially those foraged or purchased at farmers' markets, may have more dirt, leaves, twigs, or even insects on them. As a result, they usually require a more thorough washing to ensure they are safe to consume.

The texture of the mushroom variety also plays a role in the cleaning process. Mushrooms with exposed gills, such as oyster mushrooms, portobellos, and shiitakes, tend to be more absorbent than those without exposed gills, such as button, cremini, or porcini mushrooms. For the more absorbent varieties, it is recommended to use a dry approach, brushing away any dirt or debris with a paper towel, pastry brush, or mushroom brush. This helps prevent the mushrooms from becoming soggy and rubbery.

For mushrooms without exposed gills, a quick rinse in cold water followed by drying on a clean towel or paper towel is usually sufficient. It is important to wash these mushrooms just before cooking, as they can absorb moisture, which may affect their texture and cooking behaviour. Additionally, it is generally recommended to avoid soaking mushrooms, as they can absorb too much water and become waterlogged.

In summary, the decision to wash mushrooms depends on the type of mushroom and its growing conditions. Cultivated mushrooms typically require less intensive cleaning, while wild mushrooms may need a more thorough wash. By understanding the unique characteristics of the mushrooms at hand, home cooks can ensure they are properly cleaned and prepared for cooking, resulting in delicious and safe dishes.

Explore related products

Iris Hantverk Natural Mushroom Cleaning Brush - Made of Birch & Horsehair

$22.75

REDECKER Natural Pig Bristle Mushroom Brush Cleaner with Beechwood Handle, Gently and Thoroughly Cleans Mushrooms Without Water, 5 inches, Made in Germany - Mushroom Cleaner Brush

$18.99 $20.89

Valentino Garemi Mushroom Cleaning Brush – Kitchen Sink Utensil Restaurant House Use – Made in Germany

$13.99

SXhyf Vegetable Brush Scrubber for Food [Black Stiff Bristles Brush + White Soft Bristles Brush] Potato Scrubber, Dishwasher Safe Veggie & Fruit Cleaning Brush for Mushrooms, Carrots, Lemons, Eggs

$7.99 $9.99

Kitchen Craft Mushroom Cleaning Brush with Rubber Wood Handle and Soft Bristles

$9.97

OXO Good Grips Vegetable Brush Black, 1 EA

$9.92

Why some people don't wash mushrooms

There are several reasons why some people choose not to wash mushrooms before cooking them. One common concern is that washing mushrooms will make them soggy and difficult to cook. This belief stems from the idea that mushrooms are like sponges and will absorb a significant amount of water, affecting their texture and cooking time. However, others refute this claim, arguing that mushrooms are already high in moisture content and do not absorb much additional water from a brief rinse.

Another reason for not washing mushrooms is the belief that it can dilute their flavour. By washing the mushrooms, some people worry that the water will wash away some of the earthy flavours that are inherent in mushrooms. However, proponents of washing mushrooms argue that a quick rinse does not significantly impact the flavour and can help remove dirt, bacteria, and other pathogens.

Additionally, some people avoid washing mushrooms due to the fear of washing away beneficial bacteria. Mushrooms are naturally antimicrobial, which means they can kill most bacteria. As a result, some people believe that it is unnecessary to disinfect them thoroughly and that some bacteria can actually be beneficial for health.

The method of cleaning mushrooms also plays a role in this debate. Some chefs and cooks prefer to lightly brush or pat the mushrooms with a cloth or paper towel to remove dirt, rather than washing them directly with water. This method helps to avoid excess moisture and maintain the desired texture and flavour of the mushrooms.

Lastly, the type of mushrooms and their source may influence whether people choose to wash them or not. Cultivated mushrooms, which are grown in sterile environments, are considered relatively clean and may not require washing. On the other hand, wild mushrooms or those purchased from local farmers' markets may have more dirt or debris and could benefit from a gentle rinse.

How to dry mushrooms after washing

There are various methods for cleaning mushrooms before cooking them, and the right one depends on the type of mushroom and your personal preference. Cultivated mushrooms, which are grown in sterile environments, can simply be brushed off with a dry towel or mushroom brush. Wild mushrooms, on the other hand, are often covered in dirt and may require a more thorough cleaning.

If you choose to wash your mushrooms with water, it is important to dry them thoroughly before cooking. Start by gently rinsing the mushrooms in cold water, either by placing them in a colander or bowl and swirling them around. Do not let them soak for too long, as this may affect their texture. After rinsing, shake off any excess water and use a clean kitchen towel or paper towel to pat them dry. Make sure to dry the mushrooms as much as possible before moving on to the next batch. If you notice any stubborn dirt remaining, use a damp paper towel to gently wipe it away.

Another option is to use the damp paper towel method. This involves using a damp paper towel or cloth to gently rub off any visible dirt from the mushrooms. This method is less likely to result in soggy mushrooms, but it may not be sufficient for removing dirt from the crevices of wild mushrooms.

It is important to note that mushrooms should be washed and dried just before cooking, as washing them too far in advance can affect their texture and freshness. Additionally, some sources suggest that salting mushrooms before cooking can make them slimy and affect their texture, so it may be best to avoid this step.

By following these steps, you can ensure that your mushrooms are clean, dry, and ready to be sautéed or used in your desired recipe.

Frequently asked questions