The Mystery Of Manna: Mushroom Or Miracle?

Manna, derived from the Hebrew word mān, is described in the Bible and the Quran as a food substance that God provided for the Israelites during their 40-year journey through the desert after the Exodus. The biblical description of manna as small, round, and found in dew, along with its tendency to breed worms and melt when left uncollected, has led some to propose that manna refers to mushrooms, specifically the Amanita Muscaria variety. This theory suggests that the mushrooms were psychoactive and provided spiritual experiences, while critics argue that the description of manna in the Bible more closely aligns with other substances like honey or sap.

Manna is described in the Bible as a 'flake-like' edible substance, with a coriander seed-like size and white colour

Manna is described in the Bible as a "fine, flake-like thing" with a coriander seed-like size and white colour. It is said to have sustained the Israelites during their 40 years of wandering the desert after the Exodus and before the conquest of Canaan. The word "manna" is derived from the Hebrew "mān", and the Bible describes it as arriving with the dew during the night. It had to be collected before it was melted by the sun and was described as tasting like honey.

The description of manna as coriander seed-like in size and white in colour has been a subject of interest and debate. Coriander seeds are small, brown and wrinkly, with a spherical shape. Some have suggested that the reference to coriander seeds in the Bible indicates the shape and size of manna, while others propose that it signifies the preciousness of manna, akin to a fine spice. German scholar Immanuel Löw, for instance, argues that the Hebrew word refers not to coriander but to "tamarisk manna," a secretion of the tamarisk tree that solidifies into a thick, sweet substance.

The interpretation of manna as mushrooms has been proposed, with some pointing to similarities in characteristics. Manna is described as small and round, arriving with dew, and when left uncollected, breeding worms and melting. These traits are argued to be similar to those of mushrooms, especially when considering the need to dry mushrooms to prevent decomposition. Additionally, the absence of psychedelic effects in the Israelites' prolonged consumption of manna has been used to argue against the identification of manna as psychedelic mushrooms.

The identification of manna has also extended beyond mushrooms. Manna has been suggested to be a form of lichen, specifically Lecanora esculenta, which is known to form thick layers on the soil in some parts of Asia. Other naturalistic interpretations include honeydew, tree resin, syrup derived from specific plants, and a form of dew that hardens and assumes the form of a grain on oak tree leaves.

The biblical account of manna is not just a description of a substance but also carries symbolic significance. Manna is understood by some as representing all the blessings that God bestowed upon the Children of Israel as a divine favour. It is also seen as a foretaste of the promised land, described as a land "flowing with milk and honey" (Ex. 3:17). The narrative surrounding manna is interpreted by form critics as an etiological supernature story designed to explain the origin of Shabbat observance.

Manna is also referenced in the Quran as a food that sustained the Israelites during their 40-year desert wandering

Manna, described in the Quran and the Bible, is an edible substance that God bestowed upon the Israelites during their 40 years of wandering in the desert after the Exodus and before entering Canaan. In the Quran, the word "manna" appears three times: at 2:57, 7:160, and 20:80.

The description of manna in the Quran and Bible is that of a fine, flake-like thing similar to frost, which arrived with the dew at night. It is described as having a white colour and the size of a coriander seed. According to the Bible, the Israelites consumed manna for 40 years, starting from the fifteenth day of the second month (Iyar 15). It is said to have ceased appearing once they reached a settled land and the borders of Canaan.

The Israelites were instructed to gather and consume only the manna they collected each day, as storing it caused it to "breed worms and stank." However, the manna stored on the day before the Sabbath, or Preparation Day, when twice the usual amount was gathered, did not spoil overnight. This exception is noted in Exodus 16:23-24, where God commands the Israelites to bake and boil the extra manna to be saved for the following day, which they did, and it did not spoil.

The interpretation of what manna represents varies. Some describe it as edible mushrooms that grew in the land, while others believe it refers to the blessings God bestowed upon the Israelites or natural honey found in the mountains. The description of manna in the Bible has also been compared to the crystallized honeydew of certain insects, such as the Tamarisk manna scale, which was sold as "heavenly manna" in the Sinai Peninsula.

Manna is interpreted differently, including tree resin, honey, syrup, and mushrooms

Manna is a substance described in the Bible and the Quran as food that God provided for the Israelites during their 40 years in the desert after the Exodus and before they entered Canaan. The word "manna" in Hebrew means "what is it?".

In the Hebrew Bible, manna is described twice: in Exodus 16:1-36 and Numbers 11:1-9. In Exodus, manna is described as "a fine, flake-like thing" like frost, which had to be collected before it melted in the sun. It was white and the size of a coriander seed. In Numbers, it is described as having the appearance of bdellium, and the Israelites ground it and baked it into cakes. Raw manna is said to have tasted like wafers made with honey.

Some scholars have proposed that manna is related to the Egyptian term "mennu" or "mnw", which designated a white, aromatic substance that was used in offerings. Manna has also been identified with the Turkish kudret helvasi, man-es-simma, or Kurdish manna, a type of honeydew formed by aphids found in western Iran, northern Iraq, and eastern Turkey. It has also been associated with Lecanora esculenta, a form of lichen.

In a modern botanical context, manna refers to the secretions of various plants, especially shrubs and trees, and particularly the sugars obtained by evaporating the sap of the manna ash tree, which is native to Southern Europe and Southwest Asia. The sap has medicinal uses and is known as a mild laxative, demulcent, and weak expectorant.

Some believe manna was a psychoactive substance, with similarities to the shamanistic tradition

The identification of manna has been a topic of interest for many. Manna, described in the Bible and the Quran, is an edible substance that God bestowed upon the Israelites during their 40-year exile in the desert. It is described as a "fine, flake-like thing" like frost, which had to be collected before the heat of the sun melted it.

Some believe that manna was a type of mushroom, which fits the description of being small and round, and arriving with the dew during the night. It is also known that mushrooms are prone to rapid infestation with worms, as mentioned in the Bible. However, the idea that manna was a psychoactive substance is more controversial.

In his book, *The Mystery of Manna: The Psychedelic Sacrament of the Bible*, religious historian Dan Merkur presents evidence that the manna was a psychoactive fungus containing the same chemicals as LSD, and that the Israelites were initiated into a psychedelic mystery cult by Moses. Merkur's work reflects his academic background and conviction that he is correct, despite a lack of hard evidence. The book focuses on literary references to manna and journeys of ecstatic ascent, suggesting a secret tradition of psychedelic use.

The idea that psychedelics have played a role in religious traditions is not new. Shamanic religions, which dominated much of human pre-history, used trance-inducing psychoactive plants to permit direct contact with the divine. These plants were considered sacred and brought knowledge, power, and mystical insight. However, with the spread of Christianity, the religious use of psychoactive plants was suppressed.

While the evidence for manna as a psychoactive substance is not conclusive, it adds an intriguing dimension to the interpretation of biblical narratives and the role of psychedelics in religious traditions.

The theory that manna was a mushroom is disputed, with some saying the description of manna does not match that of mushrooms

The theory that manna was a mushroom is disputed, with some arguing that the biblical description of manna does not align with the characteristics of mushrooms. In the Bible, manna is described as a "small, round, flake-like thing" that arrived with the dew during the night and had to be collected before it melted in the heat of the sun. It is said to have resembled coriander seeds in size and colour, and when baked, it tasted like cakes made with oil.

Those who dispute the mushroom theory point out that the description of manna in the Bible does not match the typical appearance and behaviour of mushrooms. They argue that while mushrooms can indeed be small and round, they do not typically arrive with the dew and melt in the sun. Additionally, the process of grinding, pounding, and baking the manna into cakes is not consistent with how mushrooms are typically prepared.

The theory that manna refers to a type of mushroom is not new, and it has been a subject of debate and speculation for many years. Some scholars and enthusiasts have proposed that manna, as described in the Bible, exhibits characteristics consistent with certain types of mushrooms, particularly those with psychoactive properties. For example, small, round mushrooms can spring up overnight, especially after heavy dew, which aligns with the biblical description of manna.

Additionally, proponents of the mushroom theory highlight the importance of drying mushrooms to prevent insect infestation and decomposition, which aligns with the instruction in the Bible to bake or dry manna to prevent it from breeding worms and developing an unpleasant odour. However, critics argue that the need to dry mushrooms to prevent insect infestation is not unique to mushrooms and that other substances, such as honeydew produced by insects, can also exhibit similar behaviour.

The interpretation of manna as a divine blessing or sustenance provided by God during the Israelites' journey through the desert is central to the narrative and holds significant symbolic value. Whether or not manna specifically refers to mushrooms, the underlying message of divine provision and the spiritual significance of manna in the religious traditions remains a key aspect of its interpretation.

Frequently asked questions