Mellow Mushroom's Dough: Buy Or Bake?

Mellow Mushroom's pizza dough is a closely guarded secret, with many enthusiasts attempting to replicate the recipe at home. The dough is said to be made with spring water and molasses, which gives it a subtle sweet taste and a darker colour. The unique blend of ingredients creates a perfect mix of crisp and chewy crust that is soft on the inside and has a rich taste. While the exact recipe is not publicly available, several copycat recipes circulate online, allowing pizza lovers to recreate the magic of Mellow Mushroom's dough in their own kitchens.

Mellow Mushroom's dough recipe includes molasses

Mellow Mushroom's pizza dough recipe is a closely guarded secret, but some people have attempted to recreate it at home. The dough is said to have a subtle sweet taste and a perfect texture. While it may look like it's made with whole wheat flour, it is, in fact, made with unbromated unbleached wheat flour. The secret to its unique taste and colour lies in the use of molasses.

Typically, pizza or bread dough recipes include some form of sugar, which helps feed the yeast and allows the dough to rise. Mellow Mushroom's recipe replaces this common sugar ingredient with molasses, which gives the crust a darker colour and a more complex flavour.

To make a copycat version of Mellow Mushroom's dough at home, one would need to combine water, olive oil, and molasses in a measuring cup. The molasses is likely to be in powder form and mixed with the flour. It is important to measure out the olive oil first, so the molasses don't stick to the spoon. Next, mix flour, salt, and instant yeast together. Make a well in the middle of the flour mixture and slowly pour the water mixture into it. Use a mixer with a paddle attachment to combine the ingredients on low speed for 30 seconds to 1 minute. Switch to a hook attachment and mix on medium speed for about 15 minutes. The resulting dough ball should be slightly tacky but not sticky. Form the dough into a ball and place it in a lightly greased bowl. Cover it loosely with plastic wrap and place it in the refrigerator overnight to rise. Alternatively, it can be left on the countertop for 1-2 hours to rise.

After the dough has risen, it can be formed into a pizza crust. Parchment paper sprinkled with cornmeal can be used to shape the dough. The entire pizza should then be brushed with olive oil, and toppings can be added as desired. The pizza is baked in the oven for about 7-9 minutes or until the crust is golden brown. Once out of the oven, the crust is immediately brushed with melted garlic butter and sprinkled with Parmesan cheese.

Some people have experimented with the recipe by substituting honey for molasses and using regular tap water and fast-acting yeast. Others have used heirloom flour, which is easier on digestion, and made pretzels or breadsticks with the dough.

The dough is brushed with garlic butter

Mellow Mushroom's pizza dough is famous for its unique taste and texture. The dough is brushed with garlic butter, which adds a rich and savoury flavour to the crust. This is done after the pizza is baked and just before sprinkling the crust with Parmesan cheese. This combination of garlic butter and Parmesan creates a delicious and indulgent flavour profile that has become synonymous with Mellow Mushroom's pizzas.

The garlic butter enhances the overall taste experience, providing a buttery mouthfeel and a subtle garlic aroma. It is a simple yet effective addition that elevates the pizza to a new level of decadence. This step, along with the use of unique ingredients in the dough, showcases Mellow Mushroom's attention to detail and their commitment to creating a memorable dining experience.

The process of brushing the dough with garlic butter is an essential step in the Mellow Mushroom pizza-making tradition. It is a signature move that has gained a cult following among pizza enthusiasts. The butter used is typically melted, allowing it to coat the crust evenly and ensuring that each bite delivers the same indulgent flavour. This technique has been replicated by many pizza lovers attempting to recreate the Mellow Mushroom experience at home.

The garlic butter also serves as a flavourful base for the Parmesan cheese that is sprinkled on top. The butter helps the cheese adhere to the crust, ensuring that every bite includes a combination of buttery, garlicky, and cheesy flavours. This harmonious blend of flavours has become a hallmark of Mellow Mushroom's pizzas, setting them apart from other pizza establishments.

In addition to the garlic butter, Mellow Mushroom's dough is also renowned for its unique composition. The dough is made with unbromated, unbleached wheat flour, which is free from the toxins associated with bleached and bromated flours. This type of flour contributes to a superior taste and a healthier option for consumers. The dough also incorporates molasses, which replaces the traditional sugar used in pizza dough, giving it a darker colour and a more complex flavour.

The dough is sprinkled with Parmesan

Mellow Mushroom's pizza dough is famous for its unique blend of crisp and chewy texture and subtle sweet taste. The secret to this delicious dough lies in the use of molasses instead of sugar, which adds a complex flavour and a darker colour to the crust. The dough is also made with unbromated unbleached wheat flour and spring water, enhancing its taste and texture.

While Mellow Mushroom has not disclosed their official pizza dough recipe, dedicated food bloggers and pizza enthusiasts have attempted to recreate it through trial and error. These copycat recipes aim to replicate the distinctive characteristics of Mellow Mushroom's dough, particularly its sweet and crunchy crust.

One crucial step in achieving the signature Mellow Mushroom flavour is sprinkling the dough with Parmesan cheese. This step is typically done right after the pizza comes out of the oven while the crust is still hot. The warmth of the crust helps the Parmesan melt slightly, creating a delightful, savoury touch.

To make the perfect Mellow Mushroom-inspired pizza at home, preheat your oven to a high temperature, ideally around 500 degrees Fahrenheit. Prepare your dough by combining flour, salt, and instant yeast with a mixture of water, olive oil, and molasses. After letting the dough rise overnight, form it into a pizza crust on a surface sprinkled with cornmeal or parchment paper.

Before baking, brush the crust with garlic butter and then bake the pizza until the crust is golden brown. Finally, sprinkle the freshly baked pizza with grated Parmesan cheese, cut it into slices, and serve. Enjoy the delicious combination of the sweet and crunchy crust topped with savoury, melted Parmesan.

The dough is made with unbromated unbleached wheat flour

While I cannot confirm if Mellow Mushroom sells dough, I can provide information on the benefits of using unbromated, unbleached wheat flour.

The dough used for Mellow Mushroom's pizza crust has a subtle sweet taste and a perfect texture. It is made with vitamin-enriched, high-gluten flour with wheat germ and barley malt flour, which gives it a brown colour.

Unbromated, unbleached wheat flour is a premium quality flour milled from hard wheat, ideal for making chewy bread, such as rye bread, Italian bread, and pizza crusts. It has excellent fermentation, mixing, and machine tolerance capabilities. The unbleached quality of the flour makes a noticeable difference in the final product, as it preserves the flour's natural colour and nutritive value.

Unbleached, unbromated flour is also preferred by some bakers as it retains the flour's natural goodness and provides a product that is as close to its natural state as possible. This type of flour is suitable for a wide array of baking applications, including crusty bread, delicate pastries, and classic pies.

Additionally, unbromated flour does not contain potassium bromate, an additive used in most commercial flour and baked goods to strengthen dough, improve rise, and create a whiter appearance. Potassium bromate is a known human carcinogen and is banned in many countries. By using unbromated flour, bakers can avoid the potential health risks associated with this additive.

The dough is made with spring water

Mellow Mushroom's pizza dough is famous for its unique texture and taste. The secret to their dough is the use of spring water, which is known for its superior mineral content and lack of chlorine. Spring water has a higher pH level, which is said to be important for proper mineral content, taste, and the rise of the dough. It also doesn't alter the taste with chlorinated tap water.

The dough is made with Appalachian spring water, specifically Georgia's spring water, and is combined with olive oil and molasses. The molasses is added in place of sugar, giving the dough a subtle sweet taste and a darker colour. It also adds a complex flavour to the dough. The dough is then brushed with garlic butter and sprinkled with Parmesan cheese after it comes out of the oven.

The flour used in the dough is also unique, as it is a vitamin-enriched, high-gluten flour with wheat germ and barley malt flour. This flour is unbromated and unbleached, which is said to have a superior taste and is not filled with toxins. It is also important to note that the dough is made without any refined white sugar.

The process of making the dough involves mixing the dry ingredients, including the flour, salt, and instant yeast, and then slowly pouring in the water mixture. The dough is then formed into a ball and placed in the refrigerator overnight to rise. After resting, the dough is formed into a pizza crust and baked in the oven.

The Mellow Mushroom dough recipe yields a perfect blend of crisp and chewy pizza crust, making it a favourite among many. The combination of spring water, molasses, and unique flour creates a delicious and distinct dough that has gained a lot of popularity.

Frequently asked questions