Whataburger's Mushroom Secret: A Tasty Mystery Revealed

Whataburger's Mushroom Swiss Burger has had a tumultuous history, with a passionate fan base and a place on the All-Time Favorites menu, but it was also discontinued in April 2022. The burger features two grilled beef patties, Swiss cheese, au jus sauce, grilled mushrooms, and a toasty bun. Customers were outraged when it was removed, with some even boycotting the chain. However, in March 2025, Whataburger announced the return of the Mushroom Swiss Burger, delighting fans and inviting them to round up at the register to support a charity for military and law enforcement families.

Whataburger's Mushroom Swiss Burger was discontinued in April 2022

The Mushroom Swiss Burger was initially introduced as a limited-time offer in 2018 and quickly gained a following, leading to its inclusion on the All-Time Favorites menu in 2019. The burger's success can be attributed to its ability to remind customers of their steakhouse favorites, as noted by Whataburger's Vice President of Marketing and Innovation, Rich Scheffler.

However, in April 2022, Whataburger made the unexpected decision to remove the Mushroom Swiss Burger from the menu, leaving fans outraged and disappointed. Many customers expressed their frustration and sadness on social media and online forums, stating that the burger was the only reason they frequented Whataburger. Some even vowed to boycott the chain until the burger was brought back.

The discontinuation of the Mushroom Swiss Burger prompted a petition on Change.org, with customers pleading for its return. The petition gained over 7,200 signatures, demonstrating the strong following and demand for the burger.

In response to the petition and customer feedback, Whataburger brought back the Mushroom Swiss Burger in April 2025 as a limited-time offer to celebrate the company's 75th anniversary. The return of the burger was met with excitement and enthusiasm from devoted customers, who were eager to indulge in the savory classic once again.

The burger was a popular item

The Whataburger Mushroom Swiss Burger was a popular item, with many customers expressing their love for it. It featured two grilled beef patties, Swiss cheese, au jus sauce, grilled mushrooms, and a toasty bun. In 2019, it was added to the All-Time Favorites menu, a collection of items that were initially limited-time offers but became permanent fixtures due to customer demand.

The burger's popularity is evident in the passionate reactions from customers when it was removed from the menu in April 2022. Many customers were outraged and disappointed, with some even vowing to boycott Whataburger until it was brought back. The burger was so well-loved that a petition was started to bring it back, and customers shared how it was the only item they would order and the reason they frequented the restaurant.

The Mushroom Swiss Burger was not just a burger; it ignited taste buds and provided an incredible mouthfeel, according to some customers. It was a burger that changed people, and its removal left a void in the menu that other items couldn't fill. The burger's popularity extended across multiple states, with customers from Alabama to Texas mourning its loss.

In 2025, Whataburger answered the pleas of its customers and brought back the Mushroom Swiss Burger for a limited time to celebrate its 75th anniversary. The return of the burger was highly anticipated, with over 7,200 signatures on the petition. Whataburger's President and CEO, Debbie Stroud, acknowledged the customers' requests, stating that some legends don't belong in the past but in their hands.

Customers were unhappy with its removal

Customers were unhappy with the removal of the Mushroom Swiss Burger from the Whataburger menu. Many customers expressed their disappointment and anger on Reddit and Change.org, with some even stating that they would no longer patronize the restaurant due to the removal of the burger. One customer on Reddit said that the Mushroom Swiss Burger was the only reason they frequented Whataburger and that they would not be returning unless it was brought back. Another customer on Change.org shared that they were outraged and devastated to find that the burger had been discontinued after they had travelled three hours to visit a Whataburger.

The Mushroom Swiss Burger was introduced to the Whataburger menu in 2018 as a limited-time offer and quickly gained a following among customers. In 2019, it was added to the All-Time Favorites menu, a collection of former limited-time offers that proved so popular that the company decided to offer them for a longer timeframe. The burger featured two beef patties, Swiss cheese, creamy au jus sauce, and a generous layer of grilled mushrooms on a toasty bun. Whataburger's Vice President of Marketing and Innovation, Rich Scheffler, acknowledged the burger's popularity, stating that it reminded mushroom lovers of their steakhouse favorites.

Despite its popularity, Whataburger removed the Mushroom Swiss Burger from the menu in April 2022. This decision sparked outrage among fans, leading to a petition on Change.org to bring it back, similar to the successful petition to bring back Taco Bell's Mexican Pizza.

In March 2025, Whataburger announced the return of the Mushroom Swiss Burger for a limited time to mark the company's 75th anniversary. The company's President and CEO, Debbie Stroud, acknowledged the requests from customers and stated that some legends don't belong in the past but in their hands. The return of the Mushroom Swiss Burger was met with excitement and relief from fans, who had been eagerly awaiting its comeback.

A petition was started to bring it back

Fans of the Whataburger Mushroom Swiss Burger were outraged when the company decided to remove it from the menu in April 2022. The burger, which featured two grilled beef patties, Swiss cheese, creamy au jus sauce, and a generous layer of grilled mushrooms on a toasty bun, was a cherished item for many. Its removal led to strong reactions from customers, with some vowing to boycott Whataburger and take their business elsewhere.

In response to the menu change, a petition was started on Change.org to bring back the beloved burger. The petition, titled "Bring Back the Whataburger Mushroom Swiss Burger," garnered over 7,200 signatures. The petitioners expressed their love for the burger, describing it as "savory," "mouthwatering," and a "tastebud igniter." They also shared their disappointment and frustration with Whataburger's decision to discontinue the item.

The petition highlighted the success and popularity of the Mushroom Swiss Burger, noting that it had initially debuted as a limited-time offer in 2018 but quickly gained a loyal following. It became so popular that Whataburger added it to their All-Time Favorites menu in 2019, alongside other classics like the Patty Melt and the Honey BBQ Chicken Strip Sandwich. The All-Time Favorites menu is a collection of customer favorites that were initially limited-time offers but were brought back due to popular demand.

The petition also drew inspiration from a similar successful campaign to bring back Taco Bell's Mexican Pizza. Petitioners believed that if they banded together, they could achieve the same outcome for the Mushroom Swiss Burger. They appealed to Whataburger to listen to their customers and bring back the burger, even if only for a limited time.

The efforts of the petitioners did not go unnoticed. In March 2025, Whataburger announced the return of the Mushroom Swiss Burger as a limited-time offer to celebrate the company's 75th anniversary. Whataburger President and CEO Debbie Stroud acknowledged the customers' requests, stating, "You asked, we listened—our Mushroom Swiss Burger is back! Because some legends don't belong in the past... they belong in your hands." This victory for the petitioners and Whataburger fans demonstrates the power of customer feedback and the company's willingness to listen and respond to their devoted fanbase.

The Mushroom Swiss Burger returned in April 2025

The Mushroom Swiss Burger is back! After a three-year hiatus, Whataburger is bringing back its legendary Mushroom Swiss Burger in April 2025. This much-anticipated return is a response to devoted customers' demands and a celebration of Whataburger's 75th anniversary.

The Mushroom Swiss Burger, first introduced in 2018, became an instant hit. With its combination of two grilled beef patties, Swiss cheese, au jus sauce, and a generous portion of grilled mushrooms on a toasty bun, it satisfied cravings and reminded customers of their steakhouse favourites. It quickly earned a spot on Whataburger's All-Time Favorites menu, a collection of beloved limited-time offers that were brought back due to popular demand.

In April 2022, Whataburger made the controversial decision to remove the Mushroom Swiss Burger from the menu, sparking outrage and disappointment among its fans. Many customers took to social media and online forums to express their frustration and even declared that they would no longer patronise the restaurant without their favourite burger. Some even started petitions to bring back the beloved burger.

Heeding the calls of its loyal customers, Whataburger President and CEO Debbie Stroud announced the return of the Mushroom Swiss Burger, stating, "You asked, we listened—our Mushroom Swiss Burger is back! Because some legends don't belong in the past... they belong in your hands." This limited-time return starting April 1st, 2025, is expected to delight longtime fans and attract new customers eager to try this savoury classic.

So, if you've missed the bold and savoury flavours of the Mushroom Swiss Burger or want to experience it for the first time, head to your nearest Whataburger in April. Indulge in this legendary burger and be a part of Whataburger's 75th-anniversary celebration!

Frequently asked questions