Mushroom Picking: A Deadly Foraging Adventure

Mushroom foraging is a popular activity in many parts of the world, with deep emotional and cultural connections. However, it can be dangerous. Even experienced foragers can mistake toxic mushrooms for edible ones, as toxic mushrooms can closely resemble edible ones and may look different depending on where they grow. It is crucial to never consume wild mushrooms unless they have been identified by an expert, as mushroom poisoning can be life-threatening. Symptoms of poisoning may be delayed for many hours, and even cooking poisonous mushrooms does not make them safe.

Poisonous mushrooms can kill

Picking and consuming wild mushrooms can be extremely dangerous, even fatal. Poisonous mushrooms contain a variety of different toxins that can cause severe health issues and, in some cases, death. Of the approximately 100,000 known fungi species worldwide, about 100 are poisonous to humans.

The dangers of poisonous mushrooms lie in the toxins they contain. Mushroom toxins are secondary metabolites produced by the fungus, and they can have a range of harmful effects on the human body. Some toxins, like amatoxins, are thermostable, meaning they are not destroyed by cooking. Amatoxins quickly damage cells throughout the body and can lead to liver and kidney failure, as well as neurologic issues. Other toxins, such as psilocybin, muscarine, coprine, and allenic norleucine, can cause a range of symptoms, including hallucinations, gastrointestinal upset, and seizures.

The most common consequence of mushroom poisoning is gastrointestinal upset, which can include vomiting, diarrhea, and abdominal pain. These symptoms can be severe and may require urgent medical attention. In some cases, gastrointestinal symptoms may be the first sign of more serious poisoning, as the toxin attacks the kidneys or liver, leading to organ failure and, potentially, death.

The severity of mushroom poisoning depends on the type of mushroom, the specific toxin ingested, and the amount consumed. Some mushrooms, like the Amanita phalloides (death cap), are extremely toxic and can cause serious health issues, including organ failure and death. This mushroom closely resembles edible straw mushrooms and Caesar's mushrooms, leading to misidentification and accidental poisoning. Other deadly mushrooms include the Amanita bisporigera, found in North America and Asia, and the Galerina marginata (autumn skullcap), which is often mistaken for hallucinogenic mushrooms.

To prevent mushroom poisoning, it is crucial to never pick and consume wild mushrooms unless they have been identified by an expert. Learning how to identify mushrooms can be challenging, as the same species may have different appearances in different regions. It is also important to familiarize oneself with the toxic mushroom species similar to edible ones. If mushroom poisoning is suspected, immediate medical attention should be sought, and poison control centers should be contacted for guidance and treatment recommendations.

Symptoms of mushroom poisoning can be delayed

Picking and consuming wild mushrooms can be dangerous due to the risk of mushroom poisoning, which occurs when toxic mushrooms are ingested. While most mushroom poisonings are not fatal, they can cause a range of symptoms, from mild gastrointestinal discomfort to organ failure and even death. The symptoms of mushroom poisoning can vary depending on the type of toxin ingested, and in some cases, the onset of symptoms may be delayed.

Mushroom poisoning typically occurs due to the misidentification of toxic mushrooms as edible species, especially when they resemble each other in colour and morphology. Cooking does not eliminate the toxins in poisonous mushrooms, and even the fumes from cooking them can be harmful. Therefore, it is crucial to only consume wild mushrooms that have been identified by an expert.

The symptoms of mushroom poisoning can vary significantly depending on the type of toxin ingested. Some common toxins include amatoxins, psilocybin, muscarine, coprine, allenic norleucine, and gyromitrin. Amatoxin poisoning, for example, may not cause any symptoms for the first 6 to 12 hours, and in some cases, symptoms may not appear until days or weeks later when the toxin attacks the kidney or liver. During this latent period, the poison may be treated with silymarin, N-acetylcysteine (NAC), and penicillin G.

Other toxins may cause symptoms to appear more rapidly. For instance, poisoning from Chlorophyllum molybdites, a common cause of mushroom poisoning in North America, typically results in severe gastrointestinal distress within 1 to 3 hours of ingestion. This can include nausea, vomiting, abdominal cramping, and diarrhoea, sometimes with blood in the vomit and excrement. Similarly, poisoning from hallucinogenic mushrooms containing psilocybin and psilocin can cause altered sensorium and euphoria within 30 minutes to 2 hours of ingestion, lasting for 4 to 12 hours.

In summary, the symptoms of mushroom poisoning can vary widely depending on the type of toxin ingested, and in some cases, the onset of symptoms may be delayed. It is crucial to seek medical attention immediately if mushroom poisoning is suspected, as prompt treatment can significantly improve the chances of recovery.

Toxic mushrooms can resemble edible ones

Mushroom picking can be dangerous, as toxic mushrooms can closely resemble edible ones. It is important to never pick and eat wild mushrooms unless they have been identified by an expert. While touching or handling toxic mushrooms will not make you sick, ingestion can lead to poisoning or other unpleasant reactions. Poisonous mushrooms can grow almost anywhere, including your backyard, and they can have deadly consequences.

One example of toxic mushrooms resembling edible ones is the Shaggy Mane, or Coprinus comatus, which is a fine edible mushroom for experienced foragers. However, it appears similar to the Alcohol Inky Cap, a toxic mushroom that gets its name from its toxic component, "coprine," which is highly reactive with alcohol. Consuming this mushroom, even days before or after consuming alcohol, can cause extreme nausea, headaches, and other unpleasant symptoms.

Another example is the Giant Puffball, or Calvatia gigantea, which is considered edible when fresh and firm on the exterior with completely white flesh on the inside. However, it is crucial to bisect this mushroom to rule out deadly toxic look-alikes, such as Amanita virosa and Amanita bisporigera, which can be mistaken for Giant Puffballs once they start developing spores.

Additionally, some edible members of the Agaric family have pink to brown/black gills, a white cap, and a stout stem with a skirt. However, there are toxic members of the same family that look very similar. One way to distinguish them is by bruising the cap; if it stains bright chrome yellow, it is likely poisonous, while a pale yellow, pink, or red stain indicates edibility. Another test is to smell the mushroom; edible Agarics have a pleasant mushroomy aroma, sometimes with hints of aniseed or almond, while toxic varieties smell like Indian ink, iodine, or chemicals.

It is worth noting that cooking does not make poisonous mushrooms safe, and in some cases, simply breathing in the cooking fumes can be toxic. Therefore, it is always advisable to seek expert identification before consuming any wild mushrooms.

Mushroom identification books and apps may be inaccurate

Mushroom identification is a complex task, even for experts, due to the vast number of species and their varying characteristics. While mushroom identification books and apps can be helpful tools, they may also be inaccurate and unreliable in certain cases.

AI-powered mushroom identification apps have come under scrutiny for their frequent inaccuracies. A report by Claypool for Public Citizen, a nonprofit consumer advocacy organization, revealed that these apps often provide incorrect identifications, which can have dangerous consequences. In one instance, an Oregon family was hospitalized in 2015 after consuming mushrooms that an app had indicated were safe. Similarly, an Ohio man fell ill in 2022 from eating poisonous mushrooms misidentified by an app. The apps' reliance on AI and image recognition can lead to errors, and the absence of clear disclosures about their limitations exacerbates the issue.

Mushroom identification books, while generally more reliable than apps, are not without their drawbacks. It is impossible for any single book to cover all existing mushroom species, and regional variations in mushroom populations can further limit the accuracy of book-based identifications. Additionally, books may not be as user-friendly as apps, requiring more time and expertise to effectively utilize their content.

The limitations of mushroom identification books and apps underscore the importance of seeking expert knowledge when dealing with wild mushrooms. Poison control organizations emphasize that only experienced mycologists can provide reliable identifications, as they possess the specialized knowledge and skills necessary to distinguish between similar-looking mushroom species. The consequences of consuming poisonous mushrooms can be severe, and even non-poisonous mushrooms can cause adverse reactions in certain individuals. Therefore, it is crucial to exercise caution and prioritize expert advice over solely relying on potentially fallible identification tools.

While books and apps can serve as informative resources, they should be used cautiously and in conjunction with other sources of knowledge. Cross-referencing information from multiple sources can help verify the accuracy of identifications. Additionally, seeking out expert-led workshops, courses, or field trips can provide valuable practical experience in mushroom identification. Ultimately, the combination of reliable resources, expert guidance, and hands-on experience is the safest approach to navigating the complex world of mushroom identification.

Poisoning is difficult to treat

Mushroom poisoning is difficult to treat because of the wide variety of toxins that different mushrooms contain. The symptoms of mushroom poisoning can vary from mild gastrointestinal discomfort to death in about 10 days. The treatment depends on the type of mushroom and toxin ingested, and the speed at which treatment is administered.

Many different species of mushrooms are poisonous and contain different toxins that cause varying harm. The most common toxin that causes severe poisoning is amatoxin, which blocks DNA replication and leads to cell death. Amatoxin poisoning is treatable if quick, professional care is received. However, even with prompt treatment, mortality rates are high for certain toxins. For example, patients hospitalized and given aggressive support therapy almost immediately after ingesting amanitin-containing mushrooms have a 10% mortality rate, while those admitted 60 or more hours after ingestion have a 50-90% mortality rate.

The broad range of toxins and manifestations of mushroom poisoning requires an interprofessional approach to care for the patient. Nursing staff and physicians must be aware of the possibility of mushroom toxin ingestion, as the early presentation may appear benign, but the patient's condition can deteriorate over time. Pharmacists should also be consulted early as most of the medications (e.g., N-acetylcysteine, pyridoxine) are not readily available.

The treatment for mushroom poisoning can vary depending on the specific type of mushroom and toxin involved. For instance, patients with refractory seizures secondary to gyromitra ingestion may be treated with pyridoxine (B6), while patients who have ingested amatoxin may be treated with N-acetylcysteine (NAC), silibinin, and penicillin. In some cases, hemoperfusion may be used to remove toxins from the blood, and organ failure may require a liver or kidney transplant.

It is important to note that cooking does not make poisonous mushrooms safe to eat, and even breathing in the cooking fumes from some poisonous mushrooms can be harmful. Therefore, it is crucial to correctly identify mushrooms before consuming them and to seek medical attention immediately if mushroom poisoning is suspected.

Frequently asked questions