John Miller
Mellow Mushroom is a pizzeria located in Lima, Ohio. The restaurant is Yellow Submarine-themed, with original artwork designed by Dreamscape Art & Design that reflects the iconic design of the late sixties. Mellow Mushroom offers indoor and outdoor dining, spacious booths, widescreen TVs, and private dining rooms. The restaurant serves a variety of dishes, including pizzas, calzones, soups, salads, and wings. However, reviews for Mellow Mushroom Lima are mixed, with some customers praising the food and atmosphere while others complain about long wait times, poor service, and high prices. As of 2025, the restaurant is still in business and receiving new reviews, indicating that it is doing well enough to maintain a steady customer base.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Location | 2530 Eastown Rd, Lima, OH 45807 |
| Phone Number | (567) 289-5543 |
| Cuisine | Pizzeria, Calzones, Salads, Wings |
| Services | Takeout, Outdoor seating, Private dining room, TV screens, Full bar, Happy hour, Indoor fireplace, Late night, Non-smoking, Patio/Outdoor dining, Wheelchair access, Wine, Gluten-free options |
| Opening Hours | Mon: 11:00 am - 9:00 pm, Tue: Closed, Wed-Sat: 11:00 am - 9:00 pm, Sun: 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Theme | Yellow Submarine, Under the Sea, Hippy |
| Management | Norm & Jane Moser, Daughter Lacey |
| Art Design | Dreamscape Art & Design |
| Architect | Dave Plunkett |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
Mellow Mushroom Lima is now closed
Despite its vibrant atmosphere and interesting design, Mellow Mushroom Lima faced challenges with its service and food quality. Some customers praised the pizza, but others complained about long wait times, incorrect orders, and poor management. These issues persisted even after the restaurant management acknowledged and apologized for the problems.
One customer, who gave the restaurant multiple chances, expressed disappointment in their last three visits, particularly in December 2018. They mentioned issues with long wait times, incorrect orders, and a lack of greeting upon arrival.
Another reviewer noted that the restaurant seemed poorly managed, with slow service, indifferent staff, and warm salads. They predicted that the restaurant would not remain open for much longer due to these issues.
Mellow Mushroom Lima's last known address was 2530 Eastown Rd, and its phone number was (567) 289-5543. While the restaurant is no longer open, it once added a unique dining option to the area and provided a space for customers to enjoy sports, sunsets, and special occasions.
Crispy Portabella Mushrooms: The Secret to a Perfect Sizzle
You may want to see also
The restaurant received mixed reviews
Mellow Mushroom in Lima, Ohio, has received mixed reviews from customers. The restaurant, which is Yellow Submarine-themed, has been praised for its unique design, spacious dining area, and outdoor seating. However, some customers have criticised the service, with reports of long wait times and issues with orders.
One customer reported that they had to wait a long time for their food, even though the restaurant was not busy. They also mentioned that they had to ask for drinks, a menu, and tableware, and that the salads were served warm. They described the restaurant as "poorly run" and said they would not be returning. Another customer echoed these sentiments, stating that they had given the restaurant several opportunities to improve since it opened in 2016 but had consistently experienced issues with long wait times and incorrect orders.
On the other hand, one customer praised the restaurant for its cleanliness and interesting design. However, they found the food to be overpriced and only "just okay." They mentioned that the mushroom soup was gritty due to an overload of Parmesan cheese, and they did not care for the use of wheat bread flour in the calzones and pizza. The manager of Mellow Mushroom responded to this review, acknowledging the feedback about the cheese and apologising for the customer's less-than-great experience.
Another review mentioned that the restaurant was almost empty when they left around 8 pm, and they predicted that it would not remain open for much longer due to poor management. However, it is worth noting that this review is from 2019, and the restaurant is still operational as of 2025, according to OpenTable.
While some customers have had negative experiences, there may be improvements made since the earlier reviews, and it is always worth forming your own opinion.
Mushroom Picking: Best Time and Techniques
You may want to see also
It was Yellow Submarine-themed
Mellow Mushroom in Lima, Ohio, chose a theme based on "Under the Sea/Yellow Submarine". The original artwork of this location reflects the iconic design of the late sixties and was designed by Dreamscape Art & Design. The restaurant features a giant 3-D graphic of a smiling woman on the wall above the kitchen, adorned with a colourful collection of computer wires as her hair. Local residents will recognise the woman as Lima-born comedian Phyllis Diller, known for her "electric hair". The unique design of the Mellow Mushroom in Lima, Ohio, reflects the hippy theme of the Mellow Mushroom brand, with an actual VW Bus backing out from the bar. The entry wall above the kitchen pays tribute to the Lima Locomotive Works, a local company for which the town is well known. The bar also features metal plumbing curved upward to serve as purse hooks for patrons, as well as phone charging plug-ins with USB outlets.
Across from the bar is a room with high-top tables, a funky Mellow Mushroom-inspired Abbey Road painting, porthole windows, and a garage door that can be closed for meetings and events. This room also has a large mounted screen for television viewing or presentations. The restaurant has an open dining area with spacious booths and table seating, as well as a private dining room that can accommodate up to 24 guests and can be reserved for special occasions. The outdoor seating offers a skyline view and amazing sunsets, making it a perfect spot to catch up with friends and family.
Mellow Mushroom Lima is a casual dining pizzeria with a full bar, gluten-free options, happy hour, an indoor fireplace, late-night hours, patio/outdoor dining, and wheelchair access. They offer a variety of food and drinks, including French bread topped with melted mozzarella, creamy hummus with pita wedges or carrots and celery, sautéed spinach with artichokes and mozzarella, double-baked wings in various flavours, and a Burgundy wine and herb-infused soup. They also have a range of salad dressings, including Signature Esperanza, Herb vinaigrette, Balsamic vinaigrette, Chunky Blue Cheese, Caesar, and Ranch.
While the restaurant has received some positive feedback, there have also been several negative reviews. Some customers have complained about long wait times, incorrect orders, and poor service. One review mentioned that the restaurant was only 20% filled and that they had to wait a long time for their food and drinks. Another review from 2019 mentioned issues with long wait times and not receiving the correct orders on multiple visits, stating that they would not be returning. It is worth noting that the management of Mellow Mushroom Lima has actively responded to some of these reviews, apologising for the negative experiences and addressing the concerns raised.
Mushroom Foraging: Legalities in Pennsylvania
You may want to see also
Explore related products
It was designed by Dave Plunkett
The Mellow Mushroom in Lima, Ohio, was designed by Dave Plunkett, a world-famous architect known for his enthusiasm. Plunkett was both the architect and project manager of the Mellow Mushroom Lima project. The restaurant's design is based on the theme "Under the Sea/Yellow Submarine," chosen by owners Norm and Jane Moser. Plunkett's design includes a nod to the Lima Locomotive Works, a local company the town is known for, above the kitchen entry wall. The design also features a baby Kewpee, representing the popular local establishment Kewpee Hamburgers, which is headquartered in Lima.
The Mellow Mushroom brand is known for its hippy aesthetic, and the Lima location stays true to this with an actual VW Bus protruding from the bar. Metal plumbing curves upward to serve as purse hooks for patrons sitting at the bar, and phone charging outlets are located conveniently underneath the overhang. Across from the bar is a room with high-top tables, a Mellow Mushroom-inspired Abbey Road painting, porthole windows, and a garage door that can be closed for meetings or events. The room also features a large mounted screen for television or presentations.
The original artwork in the Lima location reflects the iconic design of the late sixties and was designed by Dreamscape Art & Design. Each Mellow Mushroom location celebrates its community with unique, vibrant creations that pay homage to the history and appeal of the area. For instance, a giant 3-D graphic of Lima-born comedian Phyllis Diller, known for her "electric hair," greets visitors from the wall above the kitchen.
The Mellow Mushroom in Lima, Ohio, is an excellent example of Dave Plunkett's enthusiastic approach to architecture and design, incorporating the brand's hippy aesthetic while celebrating the unique history and culture of the local community.
Mushrooms: Are They Deadly?
You may want to see also
It had spacious booths and table seating
Mellow Mushroom in Lima, Ohio, is a pizzeria with a unique design and a variety of dining options. The restaurant features an open dining area with spacious booths and table seating, accommodating different group sizes. The booths offer a more intimate dining experience, while the tables provide a casual and flexible option for individuals, couples, or larger parties.
The spacious booths at Mellow Mushroom provide a comfortable and relaxed dining atmosphere. These booths are ideal for small groups or families, offering a semi-private space to enjoy their meals. The booths are likely designed with privacy and comfort in mind, allowing diners to engage in conversation and enjoy their meals without feeling cramped or crowded.
The table seating at Mellow Mushroom is also generously spaced, providing ample room for diners. This table setup is versatile, accommodating couples on a romantic date, larger groups of friends or families, or even solo diners who prefer a more open and social dining experience. The tables are likely arranged to facilitate conversation and encourage a lively atmosphere.
The combination of spacious booths and table seating at Mellow Mushroom Lima caters to diverse customer preferences and dining occasions. The restaurant recognizes that some guests value privacy and intimacy during their meal, while others seek a more social and interactive experience. By offering both booth and table options, the restaurant ensures that diners can choose the setting that best suits their needs and preferences.
The design of the dining area at Mellow Mushroom Lima, including the spacious booths and table seating, contributes to the overall guest experience. The layout allows for ease of movement, ensuring that servers can navigate the space efficiently and provide prompt service. Additionally, the spacing between booths and tables helps maintain a comfortable level of privacy for diners, reducing the potential for a crowded or empty atmosphere.
In conclusion, the spacious booths and table seating at Mellow Mushroom in Lima, Ohio, enhance the dining experience by offering comfort, flexibility, and a variety of seating options to suit different occasions and preferences. The restaurant's attention to the layout and design of their dining area contributes to a positive overall impression, ensuring that guests feel welcome and accommodated regardless of their dining party size or style.
Drying Shiitake Mushrooms: Techniques and Best Practices
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
No, Mellow Mushroom in Lima, Ohio, is now closed.
The reviews for Mellow Mushroom in Lima, Ohio, were mixed. Some customers praised the food, while others criticised the service and long wait times. Several reviews mentioned that the restaurant was poorly managed.
The Mellow Mushroom in Lima, Ohio, was Yellow Submarine-themed, with original artwork reflecting the design of the late sixties. The restaurant also included nods to the local community, such as a reference to the Lima Locomotive Works and a baby Kewpee representing the popular local establishment Kewpee Hamburgers.
