Laura Smith
In the game Stardew Valley, players can choose between a mushroom cave or a fruit cave. While the mushroom cave provides a consistent supply of mushrooms, which are useful for crafting Life Elixirs, the fruit cave offers various fruits that can be used to make Artisan Goods. Players who want to change their mushroom cave to a fruit cave can attempt to modify their save file, but this is not recommended as it may break the game. Some players suggest that having the option to change the cave type after completing the Community Center or by paying a fee would be a welcome addition to the game. Ultimately, the decision between the mushroom and fruit caves depends on the player's preferences and strategy in the game.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Resetting the cave choice | Editing some lines of code within the save file |
| Using the CJB Cheat Menu mod | |
| Modding | |
| Editing the save file (PC only) | |
| Deleting " |
|
| Deleting text and replacing it with |
|
| Backing up the save file | |
| Cave choice | Mushrooms |
| Fruit bats | |
| Fruit trees | |
| Advantages of mushrooms | Set of 6 mushrooms every 2 days |
| Rare mushrooms can be turned into Life Elixirs | |
| Advantages of fruit bats | Slow but steady supply of fruit |
| Access to foraged berries out of season | |
| Helpful for completing the Artisan Bundle early on | |
| Advantages of fruit trees | Easy access to lots of fruit |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
- Fruit bats leave various fruits in the cave overnight
- The mushroom cave gives you a set of 6 mushrooms every 2 days
- Fruit trees are very expensive and have a poor return on investment
- The mushroom cave is far more consistent than the fruit cave
- Fruit is useful for players who don't intend to plant tons of fruit trees
Fruit bats leave various fruits in the cave overnight
In the game Stardew Valley, players can choose to turn their cave into a mushroom cave or a fruit bat cave. While the mushroom cave is limited to six mushrooms every two days, the fruit bat cave provides a slow but steady supply of various fruits, left by the fruit bats overnight.
Fruit bats leave different fruits in the cave overnight, including foraged berries, even when they are not in season. The spawn rate of fruits is dependent on the number of fruits already in the cave. If the cave is empty, there is a 48% chance of no new fruit, a 25% chance of one fruit, a 13% chance of two fruits, and a 7% chance of three or four or more fruits. The average spawn rate is 1.06 fruits per night.
The fruit bat cave is advantageous for players who want to make Artisan Goods, as it provides a consistent supply of fruits without having to invest in fruit trees, which can be very expensive. Additionally, the fruits from the cave can be used as gifts for villagers, as they are universally liked.
However, some players may prefer the mushroom cave as it provides a more consistent supply of mushrooms, which can be used to craft Life Elixirs, a valuable healing item. The mushroom cave also comes with a free dehydrator, and the mushrooms can be processed into Fall Seeds and crafted into Tea Saplings. Ultimately, the choice between the fruit bat and mushroom cave depends on the player's preferences and gameplay strategy.
While the fruit bat cave offers a slow but steady supply of fruits, players should note that the spawn rate can be affected by the available floor space in the cave. Uncollected fruits reduce the space for new fruits to spawn, and placing equipment or craftable flooring in the cave also reduces the available space.
Mushrooms: Horticultural Plants or Not?
You may want to see also
The mushroom cave gives you a set of 6 mushrooms every 2 days
The mushroom cave in Stardew Valley is a popular choice among players for several reasons. Firstly, it offers a consistent supply of mushrooms, with a set of six mushrooms appearing every two days. This regularity is advantageous for players who want to avoid the uncertainty associated with the fruit cave, where the spawn rate of fruit is variable.
The mushroom cave is particularly beneficial for crafting Life Elixirs, as it provides access to rare mushrooms that are challenging to find elsewhere. Common Mushrooms, Morels, and Chanterelles are the most common varieties found in the cave, and these mushrooms are essential for crafting the Life Elixir. Additionally, the mushroom cave comes with a free dehydrator, enhancing its utility for players.
While the fruit cave offers a slow but steady supply of various fruits, including foraged berries out of season, the mushroom cave's reliability appeals to players seeking a consistent source of mushrooms for crafting and other purposes. It is worth noting that the mushroom cave may be more advantageous for players who spend a significant amount of time in the mines, as it provides a dependable source of mushrooms without the need for foraging.
However, it is important to consider the limitations of the mushroom cave. Some players have expressed that the cave becomes less useful in the late game as other sources of income become more profitable. Additionally, the mushroom cave may not be as beneficial for players who intend to plant many fruit trees, as the fruit cave's offerings can supplement their fruit supply.
Ultimately, the decision between the mushroom cave and the fruit cave depends on each player's preferences and strategies in Stardew Valley. While the mushroom cave offers consistency and rare mushrooms, the fruit cave provides a steady supply of fruit that can be useful for crafting and completing bundles. Players should carefully consider their goals and playstyle before making their choice, as it is a permanent decision in the game.
Mushrooms and Acid: A Dangerous Mix?
You may want to see also
Fruit trees are very expensive and have a poor return on investment
Fruit trees are a costly investment, and it takes time to see a return on that investment. The initial outlay for purchasing fruit trees is high, and there are also significant cash costs involved in their upkeep. These include expenses for seeds, fertilisers, plant protection, labour, fuel, energy, water, insurance, and renting land. Fruit trees require a lot of care and attention to ensure healthy growth, making them high-maintenance compared to other plants.
In addition to cash costs, there are also non-cash costs associated with fruit tree cultivation, such as depreciation and opportunity costs. Opportunity costs refer to the potential revenue lost by choosing to invest in fruit trees over alternative crops or activities. For example, the funds tied up in fruit trees could have been invested elsewhere for a higher return.
The profitability of fruit trees depends on various factors, including the species of tree, the diligence of the grower, and the local demand for the fruit. Some fruit trees, like apple and pear trees, are more profitable than others due to their ability to grow well in most climates and produce a good crop with relatively low maintenance. Grape plants and cherry trees can also be profitable, even for those new to fruit tree cultivation, as they do not require a lot of special care.
However, fruit trees are generally a long-term investment, and it may take several years before a significant return is seen. This long payback period may be a deterrent for some investors, especially when compared to the potential for quicker profits from alternative crops. For example, hops can be produced daily and sold as pale ales for a higher profit than wine made from fruit trees.
While fruit trees can eventually yield thousands of dollars' worth of produce each year, the high upfront costs and slow return on investment mean that they may not be the best option for those seeking quick financial gains.
Mushroom Ketchup: Vegan-Friendly or Not?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
$14.99
The mushroom cave is far more consistent than the fruit cave
In the game Stardew Valley, players can choose between a mushroom cave and a fruit cave. While both have their advantages and disadvantages, the mushroom cave is far more consistent than the fruit cave.
The mushroom cave provides a guaranteed drop of six mushrooms every two days, which can be used to craft Life Elixirs, a valuable source of healing. Additionally, the mushroom cave is beneficial for players who spend a lot of time in the mines, as it provides access to rare mushrooms that are difficult to find elsewhere.
On the other hand, the fruit cave offers a slow but steady supply of fruit, with a chance of new fruit spawning every night. However, the spawn rate is inconsistent, and players may go a week with only a few pieces of fruit. While the fruit is useful for making Artisan Goods, players can also plant their own fruit trees to gain more consistent access to fruit.
Some players have expressed a preference for the mushroom cave due to its reliability and the value of the mushrooms for crafting and healing. They also suggest that fruit trees are expensive and have a poor return on investment.
To change the cave type in-game, players would need to edit the save file, which is a complex process and may not be allowed in all versions of the game.
Mushroom Cultivation: A Beginner's Guide to Growing Mushrooms
You may want to see also
Fruit is useful for players who don't intend to plant tons of fruit trees
In Stardew Valley, players can choose to have either a mushroom cave or a fruit bat cave. While the choice is permanent and cannot be reversed, players who don't intend to plant tons of fruit trees may still find the fruit cave useful.
Fruit is a great option for players who want to make Artisan Goods. The cave provides a slow but steady supply of fruit, especially foraged berries, even out of their respective seasons. This can be helpful for players who want to make Artisan Goods but don't have enough money to buy all the necessary fruit trees. Additionally, fruit can be a good source of income. While the return on investment for fruit trees is not always great, they can still be valuable, especially if you have a stock of them during the winter when other good items are harder to grow in bulk.
The fruit cave is also useful for completing the Artisan Bundle in the Pantry within the first year or two of the game. The bundle requires a variety of fruits, which can be difficult to obtain without the fruit cave or purchasing many fruit trees.
Furthermore, players can obtain fruit by planting trees and shaking fruit out of them every three days. However, this requires a significant amount of time and space, as trees need to be planted with one tree's span between them.
Overall, while players who don't intend to plant tons of fruit trees may not find the fruit cave as useful as those who do, it can still provide benefits in terms of Artisan Goods, income, and bundle completion.
Mushroom Haloes: Myth or Reality?
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
The choice between a mushroom cave and a fruit cave is permanent and cannot be reversed in the game. However, if you are playing on a PC, you may be able to edit your save file to change your selection.
To edit your save file, you will need to modify certain lines of code. First, make sure to back up your save file. Then, press Ctrl + F, type
The fruit cave provides a slow but steady supply of various fruits, including foraged berries, even when they are out of season. This option is particularly useful for making Artisan Goods and completing the Artisan Bundle early in the game.
The mushroom cave offers a set of six mushrooms every two days, which can be used to craft Life Elixirs, a valuable source of healing. It also provides access to rare mushrooms that are difficult to find elsewhere, making it beneficial for players who spend a lot of time in the mines.
While there is no official way to have both caves in the same game, some players have suggested that you can use the CJB Cheat Menu mod to add mushroom boxes to the fruit cave or vice versa. However, this is considered an exploit and may not be allowed in certain game communities.
