Sarah Brown
In Stardew Valley, players can choose to convert their fruit bat cave into a mushroom cave. While the fruit bat cave offers a slow but steady supply of fruit, the mushroom cave provides a variety of mushrooms that can be used to craft the Life Elixir. Players who prefer mining and exploration may find the mushroom cave more appealing, while those focused on befriending villagers may prefer the fruit bat cave. Although the decision is intended to be permanent, players on PC can edit their save file to reset the choice and opt for the mushroom cave instead.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Choice | Mushrooms or Fruit Bats |
| Decision | Permanent |
| Best for | Mushrooms are best for new players or players who want to focus on mining and exploration. Fruit bats are best for players who want to befriend villagers faster. |
| Spawn rate | Mushrooms: 6 per day; Fruit bats: 1.06 per night on average (can be up to 4 or more) |
| Resetting the choice | No in-game option to reset the choice. Editing the save file can reset the choice. |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
Mushrooms are a better option for new players
Mushrooms are generally considered a better option for new players in Stardew Valley. While the choice between fruit bats and mushrooms for your farm cave is a matter of personal preference, mushrooms offer several advantages for those starting the game.
Firstly, mushrooms are difficult to find, especially during the early stages of the game. Having a mushroom cave ensures a steady supply of mushrooms, which is particularly useful for crafting Life Elixirs, a crucial item for exploring the mines. The cave comes with six boxes that produce five different types of mushrooms, including those required for crafting the Life Elixir. Common Mushrooms can also be processed into Fall Seeds and crafted into Tea Saplings, providing additional resources for planting or selling.
Secondly, mushrooms provide a more consistent income. While certain fruits may sell for more, mushrooms in the cave spawn more regularly, ensuring a steady supply for selling and a consistent gold income.
Additionally, the mushroom cave is a good choice for players who plan to grow fruit trees. The fruit bats can provide extra fruit, but this may not be necessary if you are already cultivating your own.
It is worth noting that the decision between fruit bats and mushrooms is permanent and cannot be easily reversed in the game. However, some players have suggested ways to reset the cave choice by editing the save file, but this requires caution and a backup of the original file.
Overall, mushrooms offer a more reliable source of resources, income, and crafting ingredients for new players, making them a strong option for those starting their journey in Stardew Valley.
Gongaga Mushrooms: A Comprehensive Guide
You may want to see also
Fruit bats are more efficient for completing bundles
Fruit bats are a great option for players who want to complete their bundles quickly and efficiently in Stardew Valley. While the choice between the fruit bat cave and the mushroom cave is a significant one, fruit bats offer several advantages that make them more appealing for bundle completion.
One of the main benefits of fruit bats is their ability to provide a slow but steady supply of various fruits, including foraged berries, even outside of their respective seasons. This is especially useful for completing the Artisan Bundle in the Pantry during the early years of the game, before players have the funds to purchase all the necessary fruit trees. Fruit bats can supply items like cherries, pomegranates, apples, oranges, and more, which can be crafted into Artisan Goods for rapid gold accumulation with minimal effort.
Additionally, fruit bats offer exclusive access to certain fruits needed for the Community Center bundles, helping players finish these bundles earlier and unlock the greenhouse. While the impact of this advantage is debated, it can still provide a small acceleration towards completing bundle goals. Fruit bats also provide decent gifting options for villagers, helping to build relationships and complete related bundles.
Fruit bats also represent significant time and cost savings for players. Fruit trees can be expensive and take a while to grow, whereas fruit bats can supply the same fruits for far less investment. This is especially beneficial for players who are cash-poor early in the game. Furthermore, the quality of cave fruit increases along with the player's foraging level, and with the Botanist profession, cave fruit can be iridium quality.
While mushrooms may offer higher profits in the long run, fruit bats excel at providing a consistent and diverse supply of fruits that are incredibly useful for bundle completion. Their ability to save time and money, coupled with their exclusive fruit offerings, makes fruit bats a compelling choice for players focused on efficiently completing bundles in Stardew Valley.
Gluten-Free Stuffed Mushrooms: Are They Safe?
You may want to see also
The mushroom cave has guaranteed drops
The mushroom cave is a great option for players who prefer mining and exploration, as it provides a steady supply of mushrooms, which are typically hard to find. The cave comes with six boxes that produce mushrooms every second day, ensuring a consistent yield.
While the fruit bat cave offers a slow but steady supply of fruit, the spawn rates are inconsistent and depend on available space in the cave. The mushroom cave, on the other hand, guarantees a certain number of mushrooms each day, providing a sense of assurance for players who rely on a steady supply for crafting or selling.
The mushroom cave's guaranteed drops also contribute to its overall efficiency. Players can expect a consistent yield without having to check the cave daily, freeing up time for other activities. This reliability is particularly advantageous for players who want to focus on mining and exploration, as they can rest assured that their mushroom supply will be replenished without constant supervision.
Although the decision between the fruit bat cave and the mushroom cave is a permanent one, some players have suggested the ability to change their choice later in the game, whether through interacting with NPCs like Demetrius or Robin or through a purchasable upgrade.
How to Kill Stinkhorn Mushrooms with Vinegar
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Fruit bats are a good source of gifts for villagers
In the game Stardew Valley, players can opt for a fruit bat cave or a mushroom cave. While the mushroom cave is a popular choice for players who want to craft Life Elixirs, the fruit bat cave is a good option for players who want to give gifts to villagers.
Fruit bats leave various fruits in the cave overnight, including cherries, peaches, apples, and berries. These fruits are universal likes among the villagers and are readily accessible early in the game. They can be used to make Artisan Goods, which can then be gifted to villagers to strengthen relationships and even spark romance. For example, Leah and Harvey both love to receive wine, and several others love getting specific fruits, such as pomegranates for Elliot.
Every night, there is a chance of new fruit spawning in the cave. The spawn rate depends on the number of tiles available, as fruit only spawns on valid tiles. Uncollected fruit reduces the space available for new fruit to spawn. Fruit found in the cave can be of any quality, including normal, silver, gold, or iridium.
While the fruit bat cave offers a slow but steady supply of fruit, it is important to note that the choice between the fruit bat cave and the mushroom cave is permanent and cannot be reversed in the game. Additionally, players who have grown or plan to grow fruit trees may not need the extra fruit provided by the fruit bats.
Overall, the fruit bat cave in Stardew Valley can be a good source of gifts for villagers, helping players to strengthen relationships and pursue romantic interests.
Mushrooms: Halal or Haram?
You may want to see also
You can edit your save file on PC
If you're playing on PC, you can edit your save file to change your cave choice from fruit bats to mushrooms or vice versa. Here's how you can do it:
First, launch Stardew Valley and go to the farm whose cave you want to reset. Remove any objects you've placed inside the cave, and exit the game after saving it. It is important to back up your save file before proceeding. To do this, press the Windows Key + R to open the Run dialog box, then navigate to your save file.
Next, open your save file with a text editor such as Notepad. Press Ctrl + F, and search for "
Deleting "
After you've made the changes, close your file, launch the game, and enter your farm. Demetrius will be there, and you'll be able to choose between mushrooms and bats. Select whichever option you prefer.
Keep in mind that editing your save file comes with risks. Always back up your save file before making any changes to avoid potential issues.
Mellow Mushroom Reservations: Can You Book Ahead?
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
The decision between choosing fruit bats or mushrooms for your cave is permanent and cannot be reversed in-game. However, if you are playing on PC, you can reset your choice by editing your save file. First, backup your save file. Then, launch the game, go into your farm, and remove any objects from the cave. Go to sleep, exit the game, and edit the save file by deleting the "
Mushrooms are a better choice for new players or players who want to focus on mining and exploration. Mushrooms are difficult to find, especially early in the game, and having a mushroom cave gives you access to Life Elixirs, which are important for exploring the mines. You can also process common mushrooms into Fall Seeds and craft them into Tea Saplings to plant or sell.
Fruit bats are a good option for players who want to befriend villagers faster. Fruit and artisan goods, such as wine or jam, make great gifts and can sell for more gold than mushrooms. Fruit bats provide a slow but steady supply of fruit, which can be useful for making Artisan Goods and completing the Artisan Bundle early in the game.
Once you accumulate 25,000g in total earnings, Demetrius will visit your farm and ask whether you would like to put mushrooms or fruit bats in your cave. Make sure to choose wisely, as the decision is permanent and cannot be reversed in-game.
Every night, there is a chance of new fruit spawning in the fruit bat cave. The average spawn rate is about 1 fruit per night, but there is no hard limit on the maximum number of fruit that can spawn in one night, other than the available floor space. Fruit will remain in the cave until you collect it, but uncollected fruit reduces the space available for new fruit to spawn.
