Identifying Quality Mushrooms: A Guide To Buying The Best

how to check quality of mushrooms

Mushrooms are a versatile ingredient, adding an earthy, umami-rich flavour to dishes. However, they have a short shelf life, so it's important to know how to check their quality. Fresh mushrooms should be dry, firm, and smooth with a pleasant smell. Signs of spoilage include slimyness, discolouration, an unpleasant odour, and the presence of mould. To prolong their life, mushrooms should be stored in the fridge, ideally in a brown paper bag to prevent moisture build-up. When foraging for wild mushrooms, it's crucial to correctly identify them, as some varieties are toxic and can be deadly. Key identifiers include gill colour, the presence of scales or rings, and the colour of the cap.

Characteristics Values
Texture Fresh mushrooms should be dry, firm, and plump.
Texture Mushrooms that are slimy, sticky, drying out, or shrivelled are not fresh.
Odor Fresh mushrooms have a pleasantly earthy smell.
Odor Mushrooms with an unpleasant odor should not be consumed.
Color Fresh mushrooms are usually white, tan, brown, or golden-yellow.
Color Mushrooms with noticeable discoloration, brown or dark spots, or bruising are not fresh.
Storage Fresh mushrooms should be stored in the refrigerator and consumed within 3-7 days.
Storage Cooked mushrooms can be stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator for 3-4 days.
Storage Mushrooms should not be stored in airtight containers or washed before storage as this can ruin their texture.
Type Agarics with pink to brown/black gills, a white cap, and a stout stem with a skirt are edible.
Type Agarics that stain bright chrome yellow when the cap is bruised are poisonous.
Type Agarics that stain pale yellow, pink, or red when the cap is bruised are edible.
Type Agarics that smell chemically or unpleasant are poisonous.
Type Boletes, such as Boletus, Suillus, and Leccinum, do not have gills but have sponge-like pores and generally stout stems.
Type Chanterelles have small caps with concave centers, are yellow to golden-yellow, have wavy, upturned edges, and thicken where they join the cap.
Type Puffballs have globe-shaped white or pale tan caps and unique, densely packed spines on the cap. They are only edible if they are pure white inside.
Type Shags have tall, column-like caps with flaky shingles and numerous blade-like gills that hang over a hollow stalk.

anspore

Fresh mushrooms should be dry, firm, and smooth

When purchasing mushrooms, it is recommended to choose loose mushrooms over pre-packaged containers to allow for a quality check. Fresh mushrooms should have a dry surface and a firm, smooth texture. They should not be sticky, slimy, or shrivelled, as these are signs of spoilage. Additionally, discolouration, dark spots, and fuzzy mould indicate that the mushrooms are no longer edible and should be discarded.

To ensure the best quality, it is advisable to purchase the freshest mushrooms possible and use them within 3 to 4 days. Refrigeration can prolong their shelf life, but they should still be consumed promptly. If you plan to store mushrooms for an extended period, freezing is an option, although it may affect their texture and nutritional value. Properly stored cooked mushrooms can be frozen for 9-12 months.

When selecting mushrooms, it is also important to consider their colour. Generally, mushrooms with white gills are often deadly, while those with brown or tan gills are safer. Red mushrooms should also be avoided, as many of them are poisonous. Additionally, mushrooms without scales on the cap or a ring around the stem are usually preferred.

anspore

Slimy mushrooms are spoiling

Mushrooms are a nutritious and tasty ingredient that adds an earthy flavour to dishes. However, they have a short shelf life and are susceptible to spoilage. When mushrooms start to spoil, their cell walls break apart, releasing moisture, and forming slime. Slimy mushrooms are not ideal for consumption and indicate that the mushrooms have started to spoil. The slime itself is caused by excess moisture, which can occur during cooking or storage.

When storing mushrooms, it is important to avoid plastic packaging as this traps moisture and promotes slime formation. Instead, mushrooms should be stored in a paper bag in the refrigerator, which allows for air circulation and absorbs excess moisture. If stored in their original plastic packaging, mushrooms will start to collect moisture, discolour, and turn brown within five to seven days.

While slimy mushrooms are not recommended for consumption, if the slime is minimal, they can be washed, cooked, and taste-tested. If they taste bitter or unpleasant, discard them. However, it is important to note that mushrooms can harbour pathogenic microorganisms, such as Listeria, which can cause illness. Therefore, it is generally safest to avoid consuming slimy mushrooms.

To check the quality of mushrooms, it is important to inspect their appearance and smell. Fresh mushrooms are dry, firm, and smooth with a pleasant earthy aroma. In contrast, spoilt mushrooms may appear discoloured, shrivelled, or slimy, and may emit an unpleasant odour. It is also important to clean mushrooms properly, especially wild varieties, as they can be contaminated with dirt and debris. However, avoid washing mushrooms under running water as this can dilute their taste and affect their structure and texture. Instead, use a paper towel to gently wipe away any dirt or debris.

anspore

Avoid pre-packaged containers

When it comes to buying mushrooms, it is best to avoid pre-packaged containers for several reasons. Firstly, mushrooms have a short shelf life and are highly perishable due to their high moisture content. When placed in a plastic container, they tend to collect moisture, which leads to discolouration and the formation of slime, accelerating spoilage. This means that pre-packaged mushrooms may not last as long as loose mushrooms, and you cannot be sure of their freshness.

By choosing loose mushrooms, you can carefully inspect each one to ensure they are dry, firm, and smooth with a pleasant earthy smell, which are all indicators of fresh mushrooms. Soft, mushy, shrivelled, or slimy mushrooms should be avoided. Pre-sliced mushrooms, in particular, tend to dry out and spoil faster because cutting them increases their exposure to oxygen and accelerates moisture loss.

Additionally, buying loose mushrooms allows you to select the exact quantity you need, reducing waste. It also gives you the opportunity to choose from a wider variety of mushrooms, including those that are more interesting and flavourful, such as maitake or shiitake mushrooms, which are not commonly found pre-packaged.

Lastly, opting for loose mushrooms helps you avoid wasteful plastic packaging, benefiting both your wallet and the environment. Overall, while pre-packaged mushrooms may offer convenience, selecting loose mushrooms ensures better quality, freshness, and variety while reducing waste and environmental impact.

anspore

Identify wild mushrooms before eating

It is important to correctly identify wild mushrooms before eating them, as some poisonous mushrooms can kill. Even mushrooms that are not deadly can cause several days of digestive discomfort. Here are some tips for identifying wild mushrooms:

  • Use a field guide with images and descriptions of different mushrooms to help with identification.
  • Agarics: Edible Agarics have pink to brown/black gills, a white cap, and usually a stout stem with a skirt. There are toxic Agarics that look very similar, so if the cap stains bright chrome yellow, it is probably poisonous. If it stains pale yellow, pink, or red, it is likely edible, but you should also smell it—edible Agarics smell pleasantly of mushroom, with hints of aniseed or almond, while toxic mushrooms smell of Indian ink, iodine, or chemicals.
  • Boletes: These mushrooms don't have gills but have sponge-like pores and generally stout stems. Birch Boletes are edible and tasty and turn blue immediately when cut.
  • Maitake mushrooms: These mushrooms, also known as hen of the woods, ram's or sheep's head, grow at the base of hardwood trees like oaks. They have small, overlapping tongues or fan-shaped caps and a single white stem.
  • Chanterelles: These mushrooms are found on the east and west coasts of the U.S. and grow in small clusters among hardwoods, conifers, shrubs, and bushes, usually several feet away from the base of trees. They can be pulled apart like a stick of string cheese, and their interior is solid and white. They have wavy, funnel-shaped caps and no gills, although they may display gill-like ridges.
  • Hericium erinaceus: This mushroom, also known as the bearded tooth, hedgehog, or pompom mushroom, has a distinctive shape that resembles a lion's mane or a pompom. It grows on hardwood trees in late summer and fall, often on beech trees, and its spines grow from one group rather than branches.

Remember, it is always best to be cautious when identifying wild mushrooms. If you are unsure, it is best to avoid eating them.

anspore

Store cooked mushrooms in airtight containers

Mushrooms are a versatile ingredient in the kitchen, with a meaty texture and umami flavor. They are also delicate and perishable, so proper storage is essential to preserve their quality and flavor.

Fresh mushrooms should be stored in a porous container to promote air circulation, as they tend to get slimy and spoil quickly. Plastic traps moisture, causing discoloration, mold, and slime. Therefore, it is recommended to store fresh mushrooms in a brown paper bag, with or without paper towels, to keep them dry and prevent spoilage.

When it comes to storing cooked mushrooms, the general rule is to treat them like any other cooked food. Cooked mushrooms should be stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator. If you've already sliced the mushrooms, it's best to use them within three days; otherwise, whole mushrooms should be used within a week of purchase.

To extend the shelf life of mushrooms, you can also consider freezing them. However, it's recommended to cook them first by lightly sautéing or steaming them. Once frozen, store them in an airtight, vacuum-sealed plastic bag to prevent freezer burn.

Glow Mushroom Farming: Tips and Tricks

You may want to see also

Frequently asked questions

Fresh mushrooms are dry, firm, and smooth with a pleasantly earthy smell. If your mushrooms are soft, mushy, shrivelled, or slimy, they are no longer safe to eat. Additionally, if your mushrooms have developed an unpleasant odour, they should not be consumed.

Some poisonous wild mushrooms can kill, so it is important to be able to identify the individual mushroom you have found. Wild mushrooms with pink to brown/black gills, a white cap, and a stout stem with a skirt are members of the Agaric family. If the cap stains bright chrome yellow, it is likely poisonous, but if it stains pale yellow, pink, or red, it is probably edible. Agarics with an unpleasant chemical smell are also likely poisonous. Chanterelles are yellow to golden-yellow with a trumpet-shaped stalk and are often found under hardwood trees and conifers in the fall to early spring. Puffballs are globe-shaped with white or pale tan caps and unique, densely packed spines on the cap. They should be pure white inside; if they are yellow or brown inside, they are not edible.

Fresh mushrooms should be stored in the refrigerator and used within 3-4 days of purchase. They should not be stored in airtight containers as they will spoil more quickly. Instead, transfer them from their original container to a brown paper bag and place them in the fridge. This will keep moisture at bay and prevent spoilage.

Yes, freezing mushrooms is a good way to preserve their taste, but they will lose much of their nutritional value and texture. Before freezing, wipe them down with a paper towel and store them in an airtight bag. Do not wash the mushrooms before freezing as they will act like a sponge and absorb too much water.

Written by
Reviewed by

Explore related products

100 Edible Mushrooms

$23.42 $28.95

Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment