Crafting Pizza Express’S Creamy Mushroom Starter At Home: Easy Recipe

Making the Pizza Express Mushroom Starter at home is a delightful way to recreate the restaurant’s signature dish in your own kitchen. This appetizer features a rich, creamy blend of mushrooms, garlic, and herbs, served on toasted ciabatta bread with a sprinkle of parsley and a drizzle of olive oil. The key to mastering this dish lies in selecting fresh, high-quality mushrooms, such as a mix of chestnut and button mushrooms, and sautéing them to perfection with garlic, white wine, and cream. Adding a touch of thyme and a squeeze of lemon juice elevates the flavors, while the toasted ciabatta provides a satisfying crunch. With simple ingredients and straightforward steps, this recipe allows you to enjoy the comforting, indulgent taste of Pizza Express’s beloved starter right at home.

Explore related products

Gino Bambino Sourdough Pizza Starter Kit, Hand Stretched Stone Baked, 3 Crusts with Sauce, 45.72 oz

$21.98 $23.44

Urban Slicer Pizza Worx - At Home Pizza Pro STARTER KIT - 1 Bag Neapolitan Style Crust - 1 Pizza Sauce - 1 Spicy Cupping Pepperoni Package - 1 White Pizza Mojo Seasoning

$29.99

Presto 03430 Pizzazz Plus Rotating Oven, Black

$79 $89.99

Mrs. Wages Pizza Sauce Canning Mix, Easy-To-Use, Simple Homemade Pizza Sauce, Great Flavor, Easy To Freeze or Serve Fresh, 5 oz packet (Value Pack Of 6)

$32.9

Urban Slicer Pizza Worx - Neapolitan Style Pizza Dough - At-Home Pizza Making Kit for Classic Artisan Crust - 13.4 oz. Bag - Makes 2 Pizzas

$9.99

Ooni New York Style Pizza Dough Mix 25 oz (725g) - Makes 4 x 8.8 oz (250g) dough balls in 3 hours

$12.95

Ingredients Needed: List all fresh, high-quality ingredients required for the Pizza Express mushroom starter

Creating the iconic Pizza Express mushroom starter begins with selecting the finest, freshest ingredients. The foundation of this dish lies in its simplicity, yet the quality of each component is non-negotiable. Start with 250g of wild mushrooms, preferably a mix of chestnut, shiitake, and oyster varieties, to add depth and texture. These mushrooms should be firm, with no signs of sliminess or discoloration, ensuring a robust earthy flavor.

Next, extra virgin olive oil is essential—use approximately 3 tablespoons of a high-quality, cold-pressed variety. Its fruity notes will complement the mushrooms without overpowering them. Pair this with 2 cloves of garlic, finely sliced, to infuse the dish with a subtle, aromatic warmth. Freshness is key here; avoid pre-minced garlic, as it lacks the complexity needed for this starter.

To balance the richness, a handful of fresh parsley (about 15g) is chopped and sprinkled over the dish just before serving. Its bright, herbal flavor cuts through the umami of the mushrooms. Additionally, 50g of grated Grana Padano or Parmesan cheese adds a salty, nutty finish. Opt for a block of cheese and grate it yourself for superior texture and flavor.

Finally, a squeeze of fresh lemon juice (about 1 teaspoon) brightens the dish, enhancing the mushrooms' natural taste. Use unwaxed lemons and juice them just before serving to preserve their zesty freshness. Each ingredient, carefully chosen and measured, contributes to a harmonious, restaurant-quality starter.

Preparing Mushrooms: Clean, slice, and season mushrooms for optimal flavor and texture

Mushrooms are the star of Pizza Express’s beloved starter, but their earthy flavor and delicate texture require careful preparation to shine. Cleaning them properly is the first critical step. Avoid soaking mushrooms in water, as they act like sponges and will become waterlogged, diluting their flavor. Instead, use a damp paper towel or a soft brush to gently wipe away dirt and debris. For stubborn spots, trim them with a small knife. This method preserves their natural moisture and ensures they retain their umami richness when cooked.

Once cleaned, slicing mushrooms evenly is key to achieving consistent texture and cooking time. For a Pizza Express-style starter, aim for ¼-inch thick slices. Thicker slices can become rubbery, while thinner ones may burn or shrivel. If using a mix of mushroom varieties, such as button, cremini, or shiitake, slice them uniformly to ensure they cook at the same rate. This attention to detail creates a harmonious bite in every piece, balancing tenderness with a slight chew.

Seasoning mushrooms is where their flavor transforms from good to unforgettable. Start with a generous drizzle of olive oil—enough to coat the slices without pooling. Add a pinch of salt and freshly cracked black pepper to enhance their natural earthiness. For a Pizza Express-inspired twist, sprinkle a teaspoon of dried thyme or a pinch of garlic powder per cup of mushrooms. Toss gently to distribute the seasonings evenly. This simple yet precise approach allows the mushrooms to caramelize beautifully when cooked, adding depth to the dish.

Finally, consider the cooking method to lock in flavor and texture. Sautéing mushrooms over medium-high heat for 5–7 minutes until golden brown is ideal. Avoid overcrowding the pan, as this releases excess moisture and steams them instead of browning. A splash of white wine or a squeeze of lemon juice in the last minute of cooking can brighten their flavor. When done right, the mushrooms should be tender, slightly crispy around the edges, and bursting with savory notes—perfect for topping garlic bread or serving as a standalone starter.

Mastering the art of preparing mushrooms—cleaning, slicing, and seasoning—elevates them from a simple ingredient to the centerpiece of a dish. With these techniques, you’ll recreate the Pizza Express mushroom starter’s signature balance of texture and flavor, ensuring every bite is as memorable as the original.

Garlic Butter Base: Melt butter, infuse with garlic, and spread evenly on the pizza base

The foundation of a memorable Pizza Express-style mushroom starter lies in its aromatic garlic butter base. This simple yet transformative step elevates the pizza from ordinary to extraordinary, infusing each bite with a rich, savory depth. By replacing the traditional tomato sauce with a garlic butter base, you create a canvas that complements the earthy flavors of mushrooms while adding a luxurious mouthfeel.

Mastering the Technique: A Step-by-Step Guide

Begin by melting 2 tablespoons of unsalted butter in a small saucepan over low heat. Unsalted butter is key here, as it allows you to control the seasoning without overwhelming the garlic. Once melted, add 3 minced garlic cloves and infuse them gently for 2–3 minutes. Avoid high heat, as it can burn the garlic, resulting in a bitter taste. The goal is to release the garlic’s natural sweetness and aroma, creating a harmonious blend with the butter. Strain the mixture if desired, to remove garlic solids, or leave them in for added texture.

Spreading the Magic: Precision Matters

Using a pastry brush, spread the garlic butter evenly across the pizza base, ensuring every inch is coated. This step is crucial for consistency—too much in one area can make the crust soggy, while too little leaves pockets of dryness. Aim for a thin, even layer, allowing the butter to soak slightly into the dough for maximum flavor penetration. For a 12-inch base, 3–4 tablespoons of garlic butter is ideal, but adjust based on personal preference.

The Science Behind the Flavor

Garlic butter works as a flavor amplifier, enhancing the umami notes of mushrooms while adding a creamy, slightly nutty undertone. The fat in butter also acts as a carrier for fat-soluble flavor compounds in garlic, intensifying its impact. This technique is particularly effective in no-sauce pizzas, where the base itself becomes a key flavor component. For a modern twist, add a pinch of red pepper flakes to the butter for a subtle kick, or a squeeze of lemon zest for brightness.

Practical Tips for Perfection

If time is tight, prepare the garlic butter in advance and refrigerate it. Reheat gently before spreading to maintain its fluidity. For a vegan alternative, substitute with plant-based butter and ensure it’s fully melted before infusing with garlic. Pair this base with a mix of wild and button mushrooms, sautéed in thyme and white wine, for a Pizza Express-inspired starter that’s both indulgent and sophisticated. The garlic butter base isn't just a step—it’s the secret to a starter that lingers in memory long after the last slice is gone.

Explore related products

Napoleon Grills 90002 Pizza Lover's Starters Kit 47 inches long

$99.99

The Perfect Pizza Pack™ - Reusable Pizza Storage Container with 5 Microwavable Serving Trays - BPA-Free Adjustable Pizza Slice Container to Organize & Save Space, Red

$24.99 $29.99

Presto 03434 Pizzaz Plus Rotating Oven - 12-Inch, Countertop Pizza Oven, Nonstick Tray, Top and Bottom Heating Elements, Easy to Clean, Green/Gold

$83.47

Pizza Oven Wood with Fire Starters, 12 lbs Kiln-Dried White Oak Logs (6 Inch) for Ooni, Solo Stove, Gozney – Low Smoke, Clean Split Firewood for Outdoor Cooking & Wood-Fired Pizza, Approx 800 cub.in.

$29.56

Royal Tabletop Pizza Saver, Package of 100

$9.95

Pizza Peel Pizza Pan Set, 7Pcs Pizza Oven Accessories, 12 Inch Metal Pizza Paddle (12"x 14") with Foldable Wooden Handle, 2 Pizza Pans, Rocker Cutter, Pizza Server, Oven Mitts, Oil Brush

$31.34 $33.99

Assembling the Pizza: Layer mushrooms, cheese, and herbs on the garlic butter base

The foundation of your Pizza Express-style mushroom starter lies in the garlic butter base. This isn't just a flavor enhancer; it's the canvas upon which your mushroom masterpiece will be built. Spread a generous layer of softened garlic butter evenly across your pre-baked pizza base, ensuring every inch is coated. The garlic's pungency will mellow during baking, leaving a subtle, savory backdrop for the other ingredients.

Think of this step as priming a canvas for a painting – the garlic butter sets the tone and depth for the flavors to come.

Now, the stars of the show: the mushrooms. Opt for a mix of varieties for texture and flavor complexity. Sliced button mushrooms provide a familiar, earthy base, while shiitakes add a meaty chew and a hint of umami. For a touch of elegance, thinly slice some oyster mushrooms – their delicate texture will contrast beautifully with the others. Layer the mushrooms generously, but avoid overcrowding. You want each slice to have a good representation of all the mushroom varieties.

A light sprinkle of salt and pepper at this stage will help draw out the mushrooms' natural juices, preventing them from releasing too much liquid during baking.

Next, the cheese. A blend of mozzarella and cheddar is classic for a reason. Mozzarella melts into that signature stretchy, gooey goodness, while cheddar adds a sharp, tangy note. Grate the cheeses finely for even melting and distribution. Don't be shy with the cheese – a generous layer is key to that irresistible, bubbly topping.

Finally, the herbs. Fresh is best here. Finely chop some flat-leaf parsley for a bright, herbal note, and sprinkle it over the cheese. A few pinches of dried oregano add a touch of earthy warmth. These herbs aren't just for garnish; they elevate the dish, adding complexity and a refreshing counterpoint to the richness of the cheese and mushrooms.

This layering technique isn't just about aesthetics; it's about flavor synergy. The garlic butter base infuses the mushrooms, the cheese binds everything together, and the herbs provide a final aromatic flourish. Each layer builds upon the last, creating a harmonious and deeply satisfying starter. Remember, the key to a successful Pizza Express-style mushroom pizza lies in the balance of flavors and textures, achieved through careful layering and high-quality ingredients.

Baking Tips: Preheat oven, bake until golden, and serve immediately for best results

Preheating your oven is the unsung hero of baking, especially when crafting a dish as delicate as Pizza Express’ mushroom starter. Setting your oven to 400°F (200°C) at least 15 minutes before baking ensures even heat distribution, which is crucial for achieving that perfect golden crust. Skipping this step risks an undercooked base or unevenly melted cheese, turning your masterpiece into a soggy disappointment. Think of preheating as the foundation of your bake—it’s the difference between a professional finish and a rushed amateur attempt.

Once your oven is preheated, the next critical step is baking until the edges are golden and the cheese is bubbling. For the mushroom starter, this typically takes 12–15 minutes, but keep a close eye after the 10-minute mark. Overbaking dries out the mushrooms and toughens the dough, while underbaking leaves you with a raw, doughy center. Use the oven light to monitor progress—you’re aiming for a rich, golden-brown hue that signals caramelization and flavor development. A kitchen timer is your ally here, but trust your eyes over the clock for precision.

Serving immediately is the final, often overlooked, step that elevates your mushroom starter from good to exceptional. The contrast between the warm, gooey cheese and the crisp base is at its peak right out of the oven. Letting it sit for more than 5 minutes causes the dough to soften and the toppings to lose their vibrancy. For a restaurant-quality experience, transfer the starter to a pre-warmed plate or board to retain heat. Pair it with a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil or a sprinkle of fresh herbs just before serving for an extra layer of flavor and presentation.

Comparing this approach to other baking methods highlights its efficiency and reliability. Unlike slow-cooking or air-frying, traditional oven baking provides consistent results for dishes like the mushroom starter. It’s a technique that balances speed and quality, making it ideal for both weeknight dinners and dinner parties. While some recipes might tempt you to experiment with unconventional methods, sticking to the basics—preheat, bake until golden, serve immediately—ensures a foolproof outcome every time. Master these steps, and you’ll replicate the Pizza Express experience in your own kitchen with ease.

Frequently asked questions