Peeling Mushrooms: Is It Necessary?

There are many ways to clean mushrooms, from washing to wiping, but what about peeling? Peeling mushrooms is a common practice, often done to remove dirt and potential contaminants like tiny roundworms. Peeling is also a way to prevent the mushroom from becoming slimy and discoloured. However, it is time-consuming and removes the nutritious and flavourful skin. Some people only peel mushrooms if they are going into a salad uncooked or if they are particularly dirty. Others avoid it altogether, as the entire mushroom is edible and peeling removes a lot of the flesh. So, should you peel mushroom skin? The answer depends on your personal preference and the intended use of the mushroom.

Explore related products

Mushrooms of the Northeast: A Simple Guide to Common Mushrooms (Mushroom Guides)

$12.99 $16.95

Mushrooms (Nature Observation North America)

$8.34 $8.95

National Audubon Society Field Guide to North American Mushrooms (National Audubon Society Field Guides)

$81.78

American True Morel Mushroom (Morchella Americana) Liquid Culture Syringe Sample for Mushroom Cultivation Growing on Grain or Agar

$14.95

Blue Oyster Mushroom (Pleurotus ostreatus VAR. columbinus) Liquid Culture Syringe Sample for Mushroom Cultivation Growing on Grain or Agar

$14.95

Liquid Culture Syringe 3 Pack - Compost Mushroom Mycology Starter Pack - Grow Compost Loving Mushrooms ion agar, Grain, Straw, Compost, or Garden beds

$24.95

Peeling mushrooms is unnecessary and time-consuming

Peeling mushrooms is a time-consuming and unnecessary task. The entire mushroom is edible, and there is no reason to discard good food. The skin is the healthiest part of the vegetable, containing a lot of flavour and nutrients.

Mushrooms are grown in clean conditions, and there is no need to worry about eating them unpeeled. The "dirt" they are grown in is almost sterile, and it is safe to eat. In fact, mushroom compost is sterile, so even if you do eat some, it won't harm you.

If you are concerned about the mushrooms being dirty, there are other ways to clean them. You can wipe mushrooms gently with a damp cloth or paper towel to get rid of any light residue. Brushing is also an option, and some people use a mushroom brush or a soft-bristled cooking brush to flick away the dirt. This is more effective than wiping but can be time-consuming.

Some people also choose to wash their mushrooms, although this is a controversial topic. Mushrooms are porous, and washing them in water will impact their flavour as they will soak up water. However, one source argues that, unlike other vegetables, mushroom cell walls are made of chitin, which will remain stiff in boiling water, so they will stay crisp until all the water has boiled away.

Peeling can be done for aesthetic reasons or to remove dirt

Peeling mushrooms is a common practice for some, but not everyone agrees that it is necessary. Mushrooms are porous, and some believe that washing them will cause them to become soggy and negatively impact their flavour. Therefore, some people opt for peeling as an alternative way to clean them. The skin can also be tough when cooked, and it can be discoloured or bruised.

However, peeling can be time-consuming, and it may result in the removal of too much of the mushroom. It is also argued that the skin is the most nutritious part of the mushroom, so removing it may not be beneficial.

Some people choose to peel mushrooms for aesthetic reasons, especially if they are going into a salad uncooked. Peeling can also be done to remove dirt, and it may be preferable to washing mushrooms if you are concerned about them becoming waterlogged. Simply use your thumb to remove the stem, then grasp the edge of the mushroom and pull to peel.

If you do not want to peel your mushrooms, you can clean them by gently wiping them with a damp cloth or paper towel, or using a soft brush to remove any dirt.

Mushrooms can be washed without impacting flavour

There are differing opinions on whether mushrooms should be washed or not. Some people believe that washing mushrooms can make them slimy and less flavourful, and that the best way to clean them is to scrape off the dirt or peel them. However, others argue that it is okay to wash mushrooms, as they are already mostly water and lose little to no flavour from a brief rinse.

Those who support washing mushrooms argue that it is important to ensure that mushrooms are free of dirt and debris, and that washing is an effective way to achieve this. Chef Alex Guarnaschelli, for example, uses a knife or a damp cloth to remove visible dirt from mushrooms, but if they are particularly dirty, she washes them. Additionally, some varieties of mushrooms actually taste better after a brief saltwater bath before cooking.

It is worth noting that the belief that washing mushrooms adds water and prevents a good saute has been called "nonsense". Mushroom cell walls are made of chitin, which remains stiff in boiling water, so mushrooms will stay crisp until all the water boils away. However, it is still important to dry mushrooms after washing, as waterlogged mushrooms can develop a diluted flavour and a rubbery and slimy texture.

Some people also choose to peel their mushrooms, which can be an effective way to remove dirt. Peeling may be preferred for aesthetic reasons or to remove tough skin, especially if the mushrooms are bruised or discoloured. However, it is not necessary to peel all mushrooms, especially cultivated mushrooms, which can be cleaned using a dry cloth or paper towel.

In terms of food safety, commercial mushrooms are grown in heat-treated compost that is practically sterile, so there is a low risk of harmful contamination. Cooking mushrooms also kills any remaining germs that may be present. Therefore, it is generally safe to consume mushrooms that have been washed or peeled.

Explore related products

Liquid Culture Syringe 5 Pack - Beginner Mushroom Mycology Starter Pack - Grow on agar, grain, straw, or standard master mix hardwood blocks

$46

Gardening Complete: How to Best Grow Vegetables, Flowers, and Other Outdoor Plants

$20 $30

Mushrooms Wall Mural, Neon Forest Wallpaper, Natural Landscape Wallpaper for Bedroom Living Room, 3D Printed Background Wall Decor (Not Peel and Stick)

$139

Mushroom Wallpaper, Plants Bedroom Wallpaper, Galaxy Mural Wallpapers, Textured Wallpapers for Living Room Stickers (Not Peel and Stick)

$149

Mushroom Wallpaper Mural, Forest Wallpaper, Mysterious Jungle Murals for Bedroom Living Room, Indoor Wall Art 3D Pattern Poster (Not Peel and Stick)

$109

Mushroom Wallpaper, Plants Bedroom Wallpaper, Cartoon Custom Wall Paper, Large Wallpapers for Living Dining Room (Not Peel and Stick)

$198

Mushrooms can be brushed to remove dirt

There are many ways to clean mushrooms, and it seems that everyone has their own opinion on the best method. Some people advocate for washing mushrooms, while others believe this should be avoided due to the mushroom's capacity to absorb water. Those who advise against washing mushrooms suggest alternative methods such as wiping them with a damp cloth or paper towel, or brushing them.

Brushing mushrooms is an effective way to remove dirt and residue. It is recommended to use a cooking brush with dry bristles or a soft brush to gently brush away any dirt from the surface of the mushroom. This method is suitable for all varieties of mushrooms, including cups, Swiss, and flats.

While some people choose to peel their mushrooms, it is important to note that the entire mushroom is edible, and peeling may result in the removal of nutritious and tasty parts of the fungus. The skin of the mushroom contains a lot of goodness and flavour, and peeling can be time-consuming. However, some people argue that the skins can become tough when cooked, especially if the mushrooms are bruised or discoloured, or approaching their use-by date.

Ultimately, the decision to brush, peel, or wash mushrooms depends on personal preference and the intended use of the mushrooms. Brushing is a gentle and effective method to remove dirt and residue from mushrooms without altering their flavour or texture.

The skin is nutritious but can be tough when cooked

There are mixed opinions on whether or not to peel mushrooms before cooking. Some people choose to peel mushrooms to remove any dirt or residue, while others believe it is unnecessary and a waste of food. Mushrooms are grown in mould or manure, so some people prefer to peel and rinse them before consumption.

The skin of a mushroom is nutritious and tasty, but it can become tough when cooked, especially if the mushroom is close to its use-by date and already bruised or discoloured. Peeling mushrooms can also be time-consuming, and it may result in the loss of some flavour.

The decision to peel or not peel mushrooms ultimately comes down to personal preference. If you choose not to peel your mushrooms, it is recommended to gently wipe them with a damp cloth or brush away any dirt or residue with a soft brush or paper towel.

If you are short on time or your mushrooms are very clean, you may opt to skip peeling and simply give them a quick wipe before cooking. However, if you are concerned about any dirt or residue, or if you are following a family tradition, you may prefer to take the time to peel your mushrooms before cooking.

Frequently asked questions