Delicious Toppings To Elevate Your Grilled Portobello Mushroom Game

Grilled portobello mushrooms are a versatile and hearty vegetarian option that can be elevated with the right toppings and seasonings. Their meaty texture and earthy flavor make them a perfect canvas for a variety of ingredients, from creamy cheeses and fresh herbs to tangy sauces and crunchy vegetables. Whether you're aiming for a simple, savory dish or a more complex flavor profile, knowing what to put on grilled portobello mushrooms can transform them into a satisfying main course or a standout side. Popular choices include melted mozzarella or goat cheese, balsamic glaze, pesto, roasted red peppers, arugula, and a drizzle of garlic aioli, all of which complement the mushroom's natural richness. Experimenting with these combinations allows you to create a dish that’s both delicious and tailored to your taste preferences.

Explore related products

Savory Spice Four Mushroom Umami Blend (1.6 oz) - Salt-Free Seasoning & Gourmet Mushroom Powder for Cooking - Shiitake, Portobello, Oyster & Button Mushroom Blend - Vegan, Gluten-Free, No MSG

$13.99

香菇调味料 GIA VỊ TINH CHẤT RAU CẢI Mushroom Seasoning - 14 oz. (400g)

$13.5

Portobello Mushroom (Agaricus bisporus) Liquid Culture for Mushroom Cultivation on Grain or Agar

$14.95

McCormick Umami Seasoning with Mushrooms and Garlic Onion, 10.5 oz

$9.15 $10.91

Mushroom House Dried Portobello Mushroom Slices, 1 Lb

$29.74

9oz Shiitake Mushroom Powder, Umami Seasoning - Made of natural dried shiitake mushrooms for Risotto, Soups, Meat rubs and Mushroom Coffee, Airtight Freshness Jar

$14.99

Cheese & Herb Toppings: Melted mozzarella, feta, or goat cheese with fresh basil, thyme, or rosemary

Grilled portobello mushrooms, with their meaty texture and earthy flavor, serve as a perfect canvas for bold, complementary toppings. Among the most indulgent and aromatic options are cheese and herb combinations, which elevate the dish from simple to sublime. Melted mozzarella, crumbled feta, or creamy goat cheese paired with fresh basil, thyme, or rosemary create a symphony of flavors that enhance the mushroom’s natural richness. This pairing not only adds depth but also introduces a contrast in textures—gooey cheese against the firm mushroom, punctuated by the delicate crunch of herbs.

To achieve the ideal balance, start by preheating your grill to medium-high heat and brushing the portobello caps with olive oil to ensure even cooking. For mozzarella, slice it thinly and layer it over the mushroom gills during the last few minutes of grilling, allowing it to melt without burning. Feta and goat cheese, being firmer, can be crumbled directly onto the mushrooms post-grill, letting their tanginess stand out. Fresh herbs should be added just before serving to preserve their fragrance and color. A sprinkle of chopped basil or rosemary provides a bright, herbal finish, while thyme’s subtlety complements the cheese without overpowering it.

The choice of cheese and herb depends on the desired flavor profile. Mozzarella and basil evoke a classic Italian vibe, perfect for a Mediterranean-inspired meal. Feta and thyme lean toward a more rustic, earthy tone, ideal for pairing with grilled vegetables or grains. Goat cheese and rosemary offer a sophisticated, slightly pungent combination that pairs well with roasted meats or a crisp green salad. Experimenting with these pairings allows for customization based on personal preference or the accompanying menu.

Practical tips include seasoning the mushrooms with salt and pepper before grilling to enhance their natural flavors. For a more cohesive dish, marinate the mushrooms in a mixture of olive oil, garlic, and herbs for at least 30 minutes prior to cooking. When using fresh herbs, chop them finely to ensure even distribution and avoid large, unwieldy pieces. If grilling outdoors, monitor the heat closely to prevent the cheese from scorching—a common pitfall when working with direct flame.

In conclusion, cheese and herb toppings transform grilled portobello mushrooms into a decadent, restaurant-worthy dish. By carefully selecting and applying these ingredients, you can create a meal that is both satisfying and visually appealing. Whether for a vegetarian main course or a hearty side, this combination showcases the versatility of portobellos while celebrating the timeless marriage of cheese and herbs. With a bit of creativity and attention to detail, even novice cooks can master this flavorful technique.

Garlic & Butter Sauce: Sautéed garlic in butter, drizzled over mushrooms for rich, savory flavor

Garlic and butter—a classic duo that transforms the humble portobello mushroom into a decadent, savory delight. This combination is not just a topping; it’s a flavor amplifier that elevates the earthy, meaty texture of grilled portobellos. The key lies in the technique: sautéing minced garlic in melted butter until it’s fragrant but not burnt, creating a golden elixir that clings to the mushroom’s gills and caps. The result? A dish that’s both indulgent and approachable, perfect for weeknight dinners or as a side at a summer barbecue.

To execute this perfectly, start by finely mincing 3–4 cloves of garlic (adjust based on your love for garlic). In a small skillet, melt 2–3 tablespoons of unsalted butter over medium heat—clarified butter works well here to prevent burning. Add the garlic and sauté for 1–2 minutes, stirring constantly, until it’s lightly golden and aromatic. Be cautious; garlic burns quickly, turning bitter and ruining the sauce. Once ready, drizzle the mixture generously over the grilled portobellos, allowing the butter to seep into the mushroom’s crevices. For added depth, sprinkle a pinch of red pepper flakes or fresh parsley before serving.

What makes this sauce stand out is its simplicity and versatility. Unlike heavier toppings like cheese or creamy sauces, garlic butter enhances the mushroom’s natural flavor without overwhelming it. It’s also a time-saver—the sauce takes less than 5 minutes to prepare while your mushrooms grill. For a richer profile, add a squeeze of lemon juice or a splash of white wine to the butter as it cooks, brightening the dish with acidity. This method is particularly effective for larger portobello caps, which benefit from a bold, buttery contrast.

A practical tip: if you’re grilling outdoors, prepare the sauce ahead of time and keep it warm in a small thermos or insulated container. This ensures the butter remains liquid and easy to drizzle. For a vegan twist, substitute the butter with olive oil or plant-based butter, maintaining the garlic’s prominence. Pair the finished dish with crusty bread to mop up the sauce, or serve it alongside grilled vegetables for a balanced meal. Garlic butter isn’t just a topping—it’s a testament to how minimal ingredients can create maximum impact.

Balsamic Glaze & Arugula: Tangy balsamic reduction topped with peppery arugula and a pinch of salt

Grilled portobello mushrooms, with their meaty texture and earthy flavor, serve as a versatile canvas for bold toppings. Among the myriad options, the combination of balsamic glaze and arugula stands out for its balance of tanginess, peppery freshness, and simplicity. This pairing not only enhances the mushroom’s natural umami but also adds a sophisticated contrast in both taste and texture.

Crafting the Perfect Balsamic Glaze

Start by reducing balsamic vinegar in a small saucepan over medium heat. For every 1 cup of vinegar, aim for a 1:3 ratio to achieve a syrupy consistency, which typically takes 10–15 minutes. Stir occasionally to prevent burning. The glaze should coat the back of a spoon without dripping excessively. For added depth, incorporate a teaspoon of honey or brown sugar during reduction, balancing the acidity with subtle sweetness. Allow the glaze to cool slightly before drizzling—its viscosity will thicken further as it rests.

Arugula: The Peppery Counterpoint

Fresh arugula’s sharp, slightly spicy profile cuts through the richness of both the mushroom and balsamic glaze. Use 1–2 handfuls per mushroom cap, depending on size. Gently toss the arugula with a pinch of flaky sea salt (such as Maldon) and a light drizzle of extra-virgin olive oil to soften its bite without overwhelming the dish. Add the arugula immediately before serving to preserve its crispness and vibrant green color.

Assembly and Serving Tips

Once the portobello mushrooms are grilled to tender perfection, let them rest for 2 minutes to retain their juices. Drizzle the balsamic glaze generously over the caps, allowing it to pool slightly in their natural cavities. Top with the dressed arugula, ensuring some leaves cascade over the sides for visual appeal. For added texture, sprinkle toasted pine nuts or shaved Parmesan over the arugula. Serve warm as a standalone appetizer or alongside crusty bread for a heartier meal.

Why This Combination Works

The balsamic glaze amplifies the mushroom’s savory notes while its acidity brightens the dish. Arugula’s peppery edge provides a refreshing contrast, preventing the glaze from becoming cloying. Together, they create a harmonious interplay of flavors and textures—chewy mushroom, sticky-sweet glaze, and crisp greens. This topping is not only quick to prepare but also elevates grilled portobellos from casual to elegant, making it ideal for both weeknight dinners and dinner parties.

Explore related products

Imagine Creamy Soup, Portobello Mushroom, 32 oz. (Pack of 2)

$8.98 $11.36

McCormick Umami Seasoning with Mushrooms and Onion, 4.59 oz

$7.8

All Natural Shiitake Mushroom Seasoning Powder, Kinoko Yugo Fusion - Umami Powder, MSG-Free, Vegan & Vegetarian, 17.63oz (500g)

$14.99

Native Forest, Mushrooms Portobello Organic, 4 Ounce

$9.94

8.5oz Dried Shiitake Mushroom Powder - 100% Pure Natural Shiitake Mushroom Seasoning for Cooking, Ramen, Coffee, Sauces & Soup, No Additives, Gluten-Free & Vegan

$14.99

The Wild Mushroom Co. Dried Gourmet Mix European Mushrooms 12 Ounces (340g)

$23.99 $25.4

Pesto & Sun-Dried Tomatoes: Creamy pesto spread with chopped sun-dried tomatoes for a Mediterranean twist

Grilled portobello mushrooms, with their meaty texture and earthy flavor, are a versatile canvas for bold toppings. Among the myriad options, the combination of pesto and sun-dried tomatoes stands out for its vibrant, Mediterranean-inspired profile. This pairing not only elevates the mushroom’s natural richness but also introduces a creamy, tangy, and herbaceous dimension that’s both satisfying and sophisticated. Here’s how to master this topping, step by step, with practical tips to ensure success.

Begin by preparing the creamy pesto spread. Traditional pesto, made from basil, pine nuts, garlic, Parmesan, and olive oil, can be blended with a tablespoon of cream cheese or Greek yogurt to achieve a smoother, more spreadable consistency. The creaminess balances the pesto’s intensity and adheres better to the mushroom’s surface. For a nut-free version, substitute pine nuts with sunflower seeds or omit them entirely, focusing on the basil and cheese for flavor. Spread a generous layer of this pesto mixture onto the grilled portobello cap, ensuring it covers the gills and extends to the edges for maximum flavor impact.

Next, incorporate chopped sun-dried tomatoes to add a burst of umami and acidity. Rehydrate the tomatoes in warm water for 10 minutes if they’re too dry, then pat them dry and finely chop them. Sprinkle the tomatoes over the pesto, pressing them gently into the spread to prevent them from falling off during serving. The sun-dried tomatoes not only contribute a tangy sweetness but also provide a textural contrast to the creamy pesto and tender mushroom. For an extra layer of complexity, add a few crumbles of feta cheese or a drizzle of balsamic glaze on top.

To assemble, grill the portobello mushrooms until they’re tender but still firm, brushing them lightly with olive oil and seasoning with salt and pepper beforehand. Once grilled, immediately apply the pesto spread and sun-dried tomatoes to allow the residual heat to slightly warm the toppings, enhancing their flavors. Serve the mushrooms as a main course, paired with a side of arugula salad or roasted vegetables, or as a hearty appetizer. This combination is particularly appealing to those seeking plant-based options or a refreshing alternative to heavier toppings like cheese or meat.

The beauty of this Mediterranean twist lies in its simplicity and adaptability. It’s a topping that feels indulgent yet remains light, making it ideal for warm-weather meals or as a sophisticated addition to a summer barbecue. By focusing on high-quality ingredients—fresh basil for the pesto, premium sun-dried tomatoes packed in olive oil—you ensure the flavors shine. Whether you’re cooking for yourself or entertaining guests, this pesto and sun-dried tomato topping transforms grilled portobello mushrooms into a dish that’s as memorable as it is delicious.

BBQ & Caramelized Onions: Smoky BBQ sauce paired with sweet, caramelized onions for a hearty topping

Grilled portobello mushrooms, with their meaty texture and earthy flavor, serve as a perfect canvas for bold, complementary toppings. Among the myriad options, the combination of smoky BBQ sauce and sweet, caramelized onions stands out as a hearty and satisfying choice. This pairing not only enhances the mushroom’s natural umami but also adds layers of sweetness, tang, and depth, making it ideal for a main course or a standout side dish.

To achieve this flavor profile, start by preparing the caramelized onions. Slice two medium onions into thin, uniform rings and cook them over low heat in a tablespoon of olive oil for 30–40 minutes, stirring occasionally. The slow cooking process allows the onions to release their natural sugars, resulting in a rich, golden-brown caramelization. Patience is key here—rushing this step will yield bitter, unevenly cooked onions. While the onions cook, preheat your grill to medium-high heat and brush the portobello caps with a light coating of olive oil to prevent sticking and promote even browning.

Once the onions are caramelized, it’s time to assemble the dish. Grill the portobello mushrooms gill-side up for 5–7 minutes, then flip and cook for an additional 3–5 minutes until tender. While still warm, generously brush both sides of the mushrooms with your favorite smoky BBQ sauce—aim for 2–3 tablespoons per cap for optimal flavor. Top each mushroom with a heaping spoonful of caramelized onions, allowing the sweetness to balance the sauce’s smokiness. For added texture and freshness, sprinkle chopped cilantro or green onions over the dish before serving.

This combination is not only flavorful but also versatile. Serve the BBQ and caramelized onion-topped portobellos as a vegetarian burger alternative, paired with a side of cornbread or a crisp green salad. For a heartier meal, add a slice of melted cheddar or gouda cheese during the final minute of grilling. The contrast between the tender mushroom, sticky BBQ sauce, and melt-in-your-mouth onions creates a dish that’s both comforting and memorable.

In comparison to lighter toppings like balsamic glaze or garlic herb butter, the BBQ and caramelized onion duo leans into indulgence, making it perfect for casual gatherings or weeknight dinners. Its robust flavors also hold up well to grilling, ensuring the dish remains cohesive even when cooked outdoors. Whether you’re catering to vegetarians or simply looking to elevate your mushroom game, this topping combination delivers a satisfying, restaurant-quality result with minimal effort.

Frequently asked questions