Mushroom Strains: Does Variety Impact Experience?

The idea that mushroom strains matter is a highly contested topic. While some people believe that different strains of mushrooms produce different effects, others argue that these differences are superficial and that the cultivation process plays a more significant role in determining the potency and quality of the mushroom. Psilocybin mushrooms, including the well-known Psilocybe cubensis, have various strains that are believed to induce distinct types of experiences. These experiences are influenced by the levels of psilocybin, psilocin, and other compounds in the mushrooms. Cultivators are constantly experimenting with new strains and genetic manipulation techniques to improve yields and create highly potent mushrooms. However, the impact of domestication and selective breeding on Psilocybe cubensis has raised concerns, as modern cultivated strains may be weaker and less resistant to contamination than their wild counterparts. Ultimately, the debate over the effects of different mushroom strains remains divided, with some arguing for the importance of strain selection and others emphasizing the role of cultivation practices.

Different strains, different effects

Different strains of mushrooms can have different effects, and this is influenced by a variety of factors, including the cultivation process, genetics, and how the mushrooms are treated after harvesting.

The Psilocybe cubensis species, for example, includes strains such as Golden Teacher, B+, and Z-strain, which are believed to offer distinct psychedelic experiences. Golden Teacher, also known as Psilocybe Cubensis, is a well-known strain that is said to induce deep insights, introspection, euphoria, and a sense of connection with nature. The B+ strain is known for its large caps and thick stems, and it provides intense visuals and euphoria. The Penis Envy strain, with its distinct appearance, is known for its intense visual hallucinations and deep introspection. However, recent research suggests that these strains may be more similar than different, and the phrase "a cube is a cube" has been used to downplay the idea of unique experiences.

Psilocybe Cyanescens, or "wavy caps," is another potent strain found in the Pacific West region of the United States and Canada. These mushrooms are smaller but have higher levels of psilocybin and psilocin, the main psychoactive compounds in magic mushrooms. Psilocybe semilanceata, or "liberty caps," is a smaller strain commonly found in the Pacific Northwest and Europe, offering relative potency.

The cultivation process and post-harvest treatment play significant roles in determining potency and quality. Proper strain selection is crucial, as seen in studies with cordyceps and shiitake mushrooms, where yields varied significantly depending on the chosen strain. Additionally, selective breeding may impact traits like contamination resistance, potentially making modern cultivated strains less resilient than their wild counterparts.

While specific strains may be marketed with distinct labels, the actual differences in effects are still a subject of ongoing research and debate. Growers and consumers are advised to prioritize learning about optimal cultivation practices and experimenting with different species, as the real magic lies in how the mushrooms are grown and handled.

Strain selection impacts yield

Strain selection is one of the most important factors in successfully growing mushrooms and can have a significant impact on yield. The strain is similar to a plant breed, and different strains of the same species can have distinct characteristics and requirements. For example, the oyster mushroom (Pleurotus ostreatus) has thousands of different strains, each with unique expressions of its genetic makeup.

The act of selecting the right mushroom strain can significantly increase yields. For example, Fungi Ally's cordyceps and shiitake mushroom trials showed that yield varied depending on the strain selected. In the cordyceps strain trials, yields ranged from 3.5 grams per jar to 11.8 grams per jar. Similarly, the shiitake trials on two different substrates (logs and supplemented sawdust blocks) showed that the chosen strain significantly impacted yield. On logs, the average yield ranged from 0.5 to 2.3 pounds per log, while on sawdust, it ranged from 0.3 to 1.4 pounds per block. These variations illustrate how strain selection can make or break a mushroom-growing business.

Growers are constantly experimenting with new strains and trading them to find the best combination of strain and substrate. They purchase spawn, which is intentionally cultivated mycelium from a known species, to ensure purity and avoid contamination. The spawn comes in various forms, such as grain, sawdust, and plug, and serves as the starting point for mushroom cultivation.

While the impact of strain selection on yield is clear, it's worth noting that other factors, such as cultivation techniques and genetics, also play a significant role in determining the potency and quality of mushrooms. Ian Bollinger, a scientist known for his work in potency testing, emphasizes that potency is influenced by how the mushroom is cultivated, its genetics, and how it is treated after harvesting. Therefore, focusing on refining cultivation techniques and understanding optimal practices is crucial for growers.

Cultivation techniques matter

Cultivation techniques are crucial in mushroom farming, and various factors come into play to ensure optimal growth and yield. The first step in mushroom cultivation is selecting a suitable strain, which is similar to choosing a plant breed. Each species of mushroom, such as Pleurotus ostreatus (oyster mushrooms), has thousands of different strains, each with unique genetic expressions.

The next step is substrate preparation. The substrate should be adequately watered during this stage to provide the necessary moisture for spawn run. Maintaining the right temperature is also vital. For indoor cultivation, the ideal temperature during incubation is around 70 degrees F, although it should not exceed 80 degrees F. Higher temperatures can be tolerated when using supplemented sawdust, with the internal temperature of the bag typically 10-15 degrees F warmer than the ambient temperature.

Inoculation is another critical step. While sterility is generally not a concern for small-scale growers, it becomes crucial when using high-nitrogen materials like agar, grain, and supplemented sawdust, which are more susceptible to ambient microorganisms. Commercial labs employ various techniques, including HEPA filters and steam treatment, to ensure a sterile environment. Inoculation rates balance economics and the speed of spawn run, aiming to establish the desired edible mushroom mycelium before other organisms can take hold.

After inoculation, the incubation phase begins, where temperature plays a significant role in determining incubation time and, consequently, the number of mushrooms produced within a given space. Following incubation, the process moves to the initiation, fruiting, and harvest stages. Each of these stages requires specific techniques and conditions to optimize mushroom growth and yield.

Additionally, it is important to consider the unique characteristics of different mushroom strains when selecting a cultivation technique. For instance, growers in warmer, drier climates may need to repeatedly cross and select strains from colder, more humid regions to adapt them to their local growing environment. This process of cross-breeding and selection allows cultivators to choose strains with desirable traits, such as faster growth rates, stronger immunity, and sturdier fruiting bodies, leading to improved yield and quality.

Genetic differences

Mushrooms have thousands of different strains or expressions of their genetic makeup. The strain is similar to a plant breed. For example, the individual species of mushrooms like Pleurotus ostreatus (commonly known as oyster mushrooms) will have thousands of different strains.

The simple act of selecting the right strain can easily triple yields. For example, Fungi Ally has studied this with cordyceps and shiitake mushrooms, both species showing large variables in the correlation between strain and yield. In the cordyceps strain trials, yields varied from 3.5 grams per jar to 11.8 grams per jar. The shiitake trials were done on two different substrates: logs and supplemented sawdust blocks. Both had large variables in yield depending on the strain selected. For logs, the average yield varied from 0.5-2.3 pounds per log, with strain LE-46 performing the best. On sawdust, yields varied from 0.3-1.4 pounds per block, with strain 3782 performing the best and strain 46 doing the worst. This illustrates how some strains are developed to consume certain substrates.

Different strains of mushrooms can vary widely in their phenotypic characteristics (e.g. physical appearance, ideal habitat, resilience), and potency, which can be difficult to gauge before consumption. Psilocybe cubensis is by far the most common species of psilocybin mushroom. If you have encountered magic mushrooms before, there is a good chance it was a strain of P. cubensis. Similar to different strains of Cannabis, which all belong to the same species (Cannabis sativa), there are many strains of P. cubensis. They can differ in terms of physical features, growth characteristics, and potency. These differences are often tied to the particular environments that each has adapted to.

Some of the well-known strains of Psilocybe cubensis include Golden Teacher, B+, and Z-strain, which are often believed to have distinct psychedelic effects. However, recent research suggests that these strains may be more alike than different. Psilocybe Cyanescens, also known as "wavy caps," are potent psilocybin mushrooms found in the Pacific West region of the United States and Canada. These mushrooms are often smaller than other strains, but they contain higher levels of psilocybin and psilocin, the psychoactive compounds in magic mushrooms. Psilocybe Semilanceata, also known as "liberty caps," is a smaller strain of psilocybin mushroom that is commonly found in the Pacific Northwest region of the United States and is the most commonly harvested wild mushroom in Europe.

The potency of mushrooms is influenced by three major factors: how they are cultivated, their genetics, and how they are treated afterward. Cultivators are turning to genetic sequencing and cellular manipulation techniques to breed highly potent mushrooms. Methods to enhance the potency of mushrooms using gene-editing technology have been subject to a patent application by at least one biotech company, Intima Science. According to the document, “In some cases, the genetically modified fungi and other organisms comprise … up to 400 percent more psilocybin measured by dry weight of a fungus compared to a comparable control without genetic modification”.

Psychoactive effects

Psilocybin mushrooms, also known as "magic mushrooms," contain psychoactive compounds and fall into the category of classic psychedelics. The psychoactive effects of these mushrooms are driven mainly by a single drug, psilocybin, which is metabolized by the human digestive system into the psychedelic compound known as psilocin. Psilocybin and psilocin are the primary psychoactive compounds in psilocybin mushrooms, much like THC is the main psychoactive component in cannabis.

The variation between psilocybin strains can significantly influence the quality and intensity of the psychedelic experience. Different mushrooms may express systematically different ratios of psilocybin and psilocin, which can lead to distinct effects that vary in potency, duration, and overall experience. For example, Psilocybe Cyanescens, also known as "wavy caps," are potent psilocybin mushrooms found in the Pacific West region of the United States and Canada. These mushrooms are often smaller than other strains but contain higher levels of psilocybin and psilocin, resulting in more intense psychoactive effects.

Additionally, psilocybin mushrooms may contain other compounds that can influence the overall psychoactive effect. For instance, certain Psilocybe strains contain beta-carbolines, which are known for their psychoactive effects in other contexts, such as in the brew Ayahuasca. This suggests a possible "entourage effect" within psychedelic mushrooms, where the psychedelic experience is influenced not just by psilocybin and psilocin but also by a spectrum of other compounds.

The physical effects of psilocybin use can include nausea, vomiting, muscle weakness, and lack of coordination. The psychological consequences can include hallucinations, distorted sights and sounds, an inability to discern fantasy from reality, and intense emotions ranging from bliss to terror. It is important to note that abuse of psilocybin mushrooms can lead to poisoning if one of the many varieties of poisonous mushrooms is incorrectly identified as a psilocybin-containing mushroom. Additionally, there are health risks associated with taking psilocybin, especially in unsupervised and non-clinical settings, such as impaired judgment and coordination, which can lead to risky behaviors.

Frequently asked questions