Mellow Mushroom's Surprising Past: From Pizza To ..

what was mellow mushroom before

Mellow Mushroom Pizza Bakers is an American pizza chain that was established in 1974 in Atlanta, Georgia, by three college students with a passion for pizza. The company is known for its higher order of pizza mantra, with its signature southern-style pizza, eccentric art, and slightly sweet crust. The first Mellow Mushroom opened with a concise menu of five pizzas, four hoagies, a chef salad, and beer, all at affordable prices for college students. Today, Mellow Mushroom has expanded to over 160 locations across the United States, each locally owned and operated, offering a unique blend of art, music, high-quality ingredients, and a passionate dining experience.

Characteristics Values
Year of establishment 1974
Founders Marc "Banks" Weinstein, Mike Nicholson, and Rocky Reeves
Original location Atlanta, Georgia
Number of current locations 160+
Type of restaurant Pizza chain
Type of pizza "Southern" style, stone-baked
Menu items Calzones, hoagies, salads, appetizers, gluten-free and vegan options
Decor Psychedelic art, colourful statues, mushroom clocks, tie-dye, and colourful mushrooms
Culture Counterculture, cannabis-adjacent, 4/20 culture

anspore

Mellow Mushroom was founded in 1974 by three college students

Mellow Mushroom Pizza Bakers is an American pizza chain founded in 1974 in Atlanta, Georgia, by three college students. The original location was near the Georgia Tech campus on Spring Street and could fit only 19 people. Two of the founders, Rocky Reeves and Mike Nicholson, were roommates at Georgia Tech, and the third founder was a student at the University of Georgia. All three founders had worked in various pizza restaurants before starting Mellow Mushroom, which may have contributed to their success.

The first Mellow Mushroom menu offered small cheese pizzas for $2.50 each, Coke products for $0.30 each, and beer for $0.75 each. The chain has always been known for its affordable prices, with pizza and beer as its staple menu items. Over the years, Mellow Mushroom has expanded its menu to include calzones, hoagies, munchies, greens, sweets, and gluten-free and vegan options. Each location also offers a wide selection of beer, typically 20-40 beers on draft and 50 or more bottled.

The founders of Mellow Mushroom were self-described "hippies," and this identity is reflected in the chain's branding and decor. The restaurants feature psychedelic art, colorful statues, mushroom clocks, and unique door handles. Mellow Mushroom is also known for its focus on sustainability, using natural cardboard pizza boxes and offering all-natural meats and preservative-free cheese. The chain has a cult-like following, with customers attracted to its counterculture essence and eclectic artwork.

Mellow Mushroom has grown significantly since its founding, with over 160 locations across the United States. Each store is locally owned and operated, with its own unique decor and local flair. The chain operates as a franchise, with start-up costs ranging from $1.6 million to $4.4 million. Today, Mellow Mushroom is known for its "higher order of pizza," with a coveted secret dough recipe and red sauce that have garnered a loyal following.

anspore

The first location was on Spring Street, Atlanta, Georgia

Mellow Mushroom Pizza Bakers is an American pizza chain that was established in 1974 in Atlanta, Georgia. The first location was on Spring Street, near the Georgia Tech campus, and it could fit only 19 people uncomfortably, according to co-founder Marc "Banks" Weinstein. The company was started by three college students with a passion for pizza: Georgia Tech roommates Rocky Reeves and Mike Nicholson, who were later joined by a third partner from the University of Georgia.

The original Mellow Mushroom had a concise menu of five pizzas, four hoagies, a chef salad, and beer. Small cheese pizzas were $2.50 each, Coke products were $0.30 each, and beer was $0.75 a glass. The first location was decorated with artwork from friends and customers, often traded for pizza. The store's furniture was mismatched, as the founders had little money and had to purchase used equipment.

The Mellow Mushroom chain has since expanded to more than 160 locations across the United States, with each store locally owned, operated, and decorated differently. The chain is known for its eclectic art, featuring colourful statues, mushroom clocks, and unique door handles, as well as its "higher order of pizza" mantra and southern-style pizza. The brand encourages each location to reflect its local vibe and feature the artwork of local artists.

anspore

The original menu was affordable, with small cheese pizzas at $2.50 each

Mellow Mushroom Pizza Bakers, established in 1974 in Atlanta, Georgia, is an American pizza restaurant chain. The original menu, designed with college kids in mind, was affordable, with small cheese pizzas at $2.50 each. The menu also included Coke products for $0.30 each and beer (Budweiser, Michelob, or PBR) for $0.75 each. Pizza and beer have been staple menu items at Mellow Mushroom locations ever since. The affordability of the original menu is particularly notable when considering the current cost of pizza, where one might be lucky to get a single slice for $2.50.

The Mellow Mushroom chain was founded by three college students with a passion for pizza. Marc "Banks" Weinstein, Mike Nicholson, and Rocky Reeves started the business while attending college, with two of them working in various pizza restaurants to pay for college. The founders relied on friends and customers to help decorate the stores, often trading pizza for artwork. They had limited funds, purchasing used equipment, and none of the furniture matched. Despite the challenges, they successfully grew the business organically, seizing opportunities to open new locations.

The Mellow Mushroom menu has since expanded to include calzones, hoagies, munchies, greens, sweets, and more, with gluten-free and vegan options available. Each location is locally owned and operated, reflecting the local vibe and art of local artists. The chain is known for its trippy vibes, high-quality ingredients, and psychedelic artwork. Sustainability has been a focus from the start, with natural cardboard pizza boxes and, today, all-natural meats, preservative-free cheese, and pizza boxes with a negative carbon footprint.

The Mellow Mushroom brand has set itself apart from other regional pizza chains with its unique identity. The marketing and branding sometimes appear cannabis-adjacent, leaning into 4/20 culture with a focus on "high" and "munchies." The pizza itself is "'southern" style, distinct from the more popular New York or Chicago styles. The original dough recipe and red sauce have garnered a cult-like following, with each location offering its own local flair.

anspore

The brand's marketing and branding appears cannabis-adjacent

Mellow Mushroom Pizza Bakers is an American pizza chain founded in 1974 in Atlanta, Georgia. The chain has over 160 locations across the United States. Each location is locally owned and operated, with its own unique artwork and decor reflecting the local vibe and art of local artists. The brand is known for its "higher order of pizza" mantra, southern-style pizza, and eclectic art.

The brand's marketing and branding appear to be cannabis-adjacent, with a focus on all things "high", "munchies", and "edible". The art is often psychedelic, featuring bright colors and mushroom themes. The chain's mascot, Mel O. Mushroom, and other animated characters were created by Atlanta artist Buddy Finethy. The founders of Mellow Mushroom have described themselves as "hippies", and the brand has a focus on sustainability, using natural cardboard pizza boxes and offering all-natural meats and preservative-free cheese.

The original Mellow Mushroom location in 1974 offered small cheese pizzas for $2.50 each, alongside Coke products for $0.30 each and beer for $0.75 each. The brand's marketing has naturally appealed to college students, with affordable prices and a focus on pizza and beer. The chain has a cult-like following and a counterculture essence, blending the boundaries between art, music, high-quality ingredients, and passionate standards for dining.

Mellow Mushroom's marketing and branding strategy appears to be successful, with the brand expanding to over 160 locations across the United States and gaining a cult-like following. The brand's focus on local ownership and unique artwork at each location adds to its appeal, and its sustainability efforts and high-quality ingredients attract health-conscious consumers. The psychedelic art and cannabis-adjacent branding further enhance the brand's unique and eclectic image.

anspore

Mellow Mushroom has grown organically, now with 160+ locations

Mellow Mushroom has come a long way since its humble beginnings in 1974. The pizza chain was founded by three college students with a passion for pizza and a penchant for entrepreneurship. With a focus on affordable prices, a concise menu, and a unique brand identity, Mellow Mushroom quickly became a favourite among college students and the local community in Atlanta, Georgia.

What set Mellow Mushroom apart from the beginning was its emphasis on affordability and its distinctive brand identity. The original Mellow Mushroom location on Spring Street in Atlanta, Georgia offered small cheese pizzas for just $2.50 each, with Coke products and beer also available at very reasonable prices. This student-friendly pricing, combined with a dedication to high-quality ingredients and a "higher order of pizza" mantra, created a winning formula that attracted a loyal following.

The founders of Mellow Mushroom, including Marc "Banks" Weinstein, Mike Nicholson, and Rocky Reeves, attribute the company's growth to organic expansion. They seized opportunities to open new locations as they arose, focusing on the Southeast region of the United States. For 12 years, they operated the original six Mellow Mushrooms, encountering challenges along the way due to the lack of cell phones and the difficulty of managing multiple locations simultaneously.

Today, Mellow Mushroom has expanded to over 160 locations across 18 states, with each store being locally owned and operated, decorated to reflect the local vibe and art of the community it serves. The chain has stayed true to its roots, with pizza and beer remaining staple menu items, alongside calzones, hoagies, salads, appetizers, and a wide selection of local beers. Each location embraces the trippy vibes and psychedelic artwork that have become synonymous with the Mellow Mushroom brand, creating a dining experience that blends art, music, and high-quality ingredients.

The success of Mellow Mushroom can be attributed to its organic growth strategy, its focus on affordability and quality, and its embrace of a unique brand identity that resonates with its customers. With a cult-like following and a presence across the United States, Mellow Mushroom has become a beloved fixture in the world of pizza chains.

Mushrooms: Legume or Not?

You may want to see also

Frequently asked questions

Mellow Mushroom was established in 1974 in Atlanta, Georgia, by two college students from Georgia Tech, Rocky Reeves and Mike Nicholson, who were later joined by a third from the University of Georgia, Marc "Banks" Weinstein. The trio launched the business with a concise menu of pizzas, hoagies, salads, and beer.

The first Mellow Mushroom was opened on Spring Street in Atlanta, near the Georgia Tech campus.

The first Mellow Mushroom menu offered small cheese pizzas at $2.50 each for an entire pie, alongside Coke products for $0.30 each and beer for $0.75 each.

The Mellow Mushroom founders were college students with years of prior pizza experience, having worked in various pizza restaurants to pay for college.

Mellow Mushroom's branding is known for its trippy vibes, psychedelic artwork, and eclectic art. Each location is locally owned and operated, reflecting the local vibe and art of local artists.

Written by
Reviewed by

Explore related products

Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment