John Miller
In the video game Dark Souls, players can join the Forest Hunter covenant. A covenant is a group of NPCs with a shared mission. The Forest Hunters' mission is to protect the grave of Artorias. Joining the Forest Hunters makes the mushroom people non-hostile towards you. However, killing any mushroom people, trees, hunters, ghosts, or the catbear will break the covenant. Betraying the Forest Hunters by attacking one of these NPCs will result in a ban from the covenant and the NPCs will begin attacking you.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| What constitutes betrayal of the Forest Hunter covenant? | Killing an NPC in the covenant, including Alvina, Shiva, and the Clan of Forest Protectors. Walking or rolling into a hunter in the forest can also count as betrayal. |
| What are the consequences of betrayal? | Breaking the covenant, which can result in NPCs attacking the player and being banned from the covenant. |
| How can betrayal be avoided? | By not killing any covenant members or NPCs, and being careful not to accidentally harm NPCs through actions such as knocking them off cliffs. |
| Are there any benefits to joining the covenant? | Yes, members gain access to Alvina, who offers items and merchant services. The covenant also makes the small mushroom people friendly towards the player and dodges betrayal penalties when switching covenants. |
| Are there any consequences of joining the covenant? | Yes, it will count as a sin, but there do not appear to be any negative consequences beyond Oswald telling you that you have sinned. |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
Killing NPCs in the covenant is considered a betrayal
Players should be aware that even causing an NPC's death indirectly, such as by knocking them off a cliff, will count as a betrayal. This can be a frustrating mechanic, as evidenced by players sharing their experiences online. One player shared that they were unexpectedly charged with betrayal when an NPC jumped off a cliff by itself. Another player warned that even walking or rolling into an NPC can be counted as a betrayal.
To avoid these pitfalls, one player suggests joining the covenant, leaving the area, and only returning when ready to complete the area and the covenant tasks. Another player recommends killing everything in the area before entering the covenant, so you don't risk accidentally killing an NPC and breaking the covenant.
It's worth noting that joining the Forest Hunter covenant will make the small mushroom people friendly towards you. However, killing them is considered a betrayal, so it's best to avoid interacting with them while in the covenant.
Mushrooms: A Low-Residue Superfood?
You may want to see also
Killing any forest protectors will count as a betrayal
It is important to note that defeating trespassers or killing hostile creatures in the area does not seem to affect your covenant status. However, players should be cautious as even causing the death of an NPC indirectly, such as by falling off a cliff, can result in a broken covenant.
To avoid any accidental betrayals, some players suggest leaving the area after joining the covenant and only returning when ready to complete the area. Additionally, players can choose to kill everything in the area before entering the covenant, reducing the risk of accidentally breaking it.
While being a member of the Forest Hunter covenant, players gain access to Alvina and her merchant services. The covenant also makes the small mushroom people friendly towards the player. However, killing these mushroom people or any other forest protectors will result in a broken covenant.
Toffu and Mushrooms: What's the Difference?
You may want to see also
Attacking hunters in the forest can be counted as a betrayal
When you join the Forest Hunter covenant, you will make a sin, regardless of how you do it. Joining the covenant will make the small mushroom people friendly towards you. However, attacking one of the NPC members of the covenant can be counted as a betrayal. Betrayal can also occur when you kill an NPC in the covenant, including the forest NPCs in Darkroot Garden and Shiva of the East.
Killing all Clan of Forest Protectors and then joining the covenant will not make them hostile once they've respawned. If a member of the Forest Hunters gets summoned as a phantom by another player, they will not incur a betrayal penalty for killing covenant members or NPCs.
Additionally, when speaking to Alvina for the first time, answering "No" to her first prompt will count as a betrayal, and she will refuse to talk afterward. This can be resolved by requesting Absolution from Oswald. Making an attempt to kill Alvina will also result in breaking the covenant.
It is important to note that even if one of the monsters in the forest falls off a cliff while you are in the area, this will count as breaking the covenant.
Mushroom Pinning: What Are the Main Causes?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Killing NPCs before joining the covenant will not make them hostile
When it comes to the Forest Hunter covenant in Dark Souls, there are certain actions that can be considered a betrayal, leading to consequences such as NPCs becoming hostile. However, it's important to understand that killing NPCs before joining the covenant will typically not make them hostile towards you. The concept of betrayal within the covenant revolves around attacking or killing NPC members of the Forest Hunter covenant itself.
Specifically, betrayal is associated with killing NPCs like Alvina, Shiva, and the non-hostile NPC hunters in the forest. These NPCs are considered members of the covenant, and harming them is seen as breaking the rules of the group. It's worth noting that even accidentally causing the death of these NPCs, such as by knocking them off a cliff, can be considered a betrayal.
Now, let's address the mushrooms. The mushrooms, or mushroom people, are generally neutral creatures in the forest. Killing them does not seem to affect your covenant status, and they are not specifically mentioned in the context of betrayal. However, it's important to note that some players have reported farming the mushrooms for resin without any negative consequences. This suggests that killing the mushrooms before or after joining the covenant does not make them hostile and is not considered a betrayal.
To avoid any potential issues, it's recommended to be cautious when interacting with NPCs and creatures in the forest. Joining the Forest Hunter covenant can make the small mushroom people friendly towards you, so killing them beforehand may not have a significant impact on your relationship with them afterward. Additionally, some players suggest completing tasks outside the forest to avoid accidental covenant betrayal due to the unpredictable nature of NPCs.
In summary, killing NPCs before joining the Forest Hunter covenant will generally not make them hostile. The focus of betrayal is on harming NPC members of the covenant, such as Alvina and Shiva. While killing the mushrooms doesn't seem to count as betrayal, joining the covenant can make them friendly towards you. To be safe, it's best to avoid taking actions that could be interpreted as breaking the covenant's rules.
Mushroom Mysteries: Cap Designs and Their Functions
You may want to see also
Killing mushrooms does not count as a betrayal
However, it is extremely easy to break the covenant in other ways, such as by killing an NPC in the covenant, including Alvina, Shiva, and the forest NPCs in Darkroot Garden. Even accidentally knocking an NPC off a cliff while in the area can count as a broken covenant. Betraying the covenant can have serious consequences, such as a large soul cost to be forgiven and re-enter it.
To avoid accidentally betraying the covenant, some players suggest leaving the area after joining and only returning once you are ready to complete the area. Another tip is to kill everything in the area before entering the covenant, so you don't risk accidentally killing an NPC.
It's worth noting that the Forest Hunter covenant also comes with benefits, such as making the Forest Hunter NPCs passive and dodging betrayal penalties when switching covenants. Additionally, a merchant and a couple of items from Alvina become accessible to members of the covenant.
Making Mushroom Popcorn: A Step-by-Step Guide
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
Betrayal in the Forest Hunter covenant involves killing an NPC in the covenant. This includes the forest NPCs in Darkroot Garden, Shiva of the East, and Alvina.
If you betray the covenant, you will be banned from it and the NPC hunters will begin attacking you. You may be able to request Absolution from Oswald to resolve this.
Yes, killing the Mushroom Parents and Mushroom Children in the Darkroot Garden area counts as betrayal.
